The_Motion_Picture_Novelization.jpg?utm_source=en.wikipedia.org&utm_campaign=parser&utm_content=thumbnail_unscaled

I like the Star Trek movies (some more than others), but I would have liked them more if they had hewed closer to the novelizations, which delved deeper into the characterizations and backstories of Sulu, Scott, Saavik, etc. Unique among them is the novelization of Star Trek: The Motion Picture the only one written by by Gene Roddenberry (who often relied on footnotes to expand upon plot points). I've got a wild hair to re-read that one, and I may go beyond that, we'll see. In the meantime, I intend to use this thread as a repository for notes on plot points someone familiar only with the movies would have been unaware of.

Chapter One

As was the custom in Starfleet -- indeed, it was a requirement -- [Kirk] had been implanted with a senceiver on receiving his first command. It was the ultimate signal device, reserved for use in only the gravest of emergencies -- and this was only the second time that Starfleet Command had ever intruded into his mind in this fashion.*

*Editor's note: At the time of these events, Starfleet Command's senceiver implants were still being kept secret. Undoubtedly, the admiralty was concerned that the public might mistakenly believe them to be some sort of mind-control device. Clearly, public respect for Starfleet would have been seriously imperiled by anything reminiscent of the horrors that grew out of the politicalizing of behavior-contro  implants and which led to the bloody Mind control Revolts of 2043-47.

You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!

Join Captain Comics

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Timeline

    The timeline that runs throughout these novels (McIntyre's as well as Dillards) is consistant, but it's about three years off from the one I am using. This discrepancy is due to what I have come to call "the cluster effect." Although STII-V were released over a period of seven years, they are "clustered toghether" within a span of two years, story time. The novelizations center those on 2282 ("The Wrath of Khan" 1982), but the timeline I am using, centers on 2286 ("The Voyage Home" 1986). 

    Crew

    Kirk, McCoy and Scott are all set to retire in three months. Although still in the prime of his life, Spock is going to retire as well (out of loyalty to Captain Kirk, Uhura believes). Chekov plans to transfer off Enterprise and "was toying with the notion of leaving the Fleet." [According to the novelization of "Relics," he eventually became commandant of Starfleet Acadamy.] Uhura plans to go back to teaching at the Acadamy. And, of course, Sulu is captain of the Excelsior.

    Starfleet's commander-in-chief, Admiral William "Bill" Smillie, is the youngest individual ever to achieve the position of C-in-C.

    "Old  Vulcan Saying"

    There is one line in in the movie I have never understood. I was looking to the novelization to clear it up for me. After the briefing in which Spock recommends Captain Kirk and the Enterprise to lead the delegation to welcome the Klingons (during which he cites and "old Vulcan saying"), Kirk confronts Spock and says, "You should have trusted me," Trusted him to do what, exactly? How does recommending him to lead a diplomatic mission convey a lack of trust? In the novelization, Kirk says, "At some point, you'll realize you should have listened to me." That makes sense. Incidentally, this a goos example is what I've been talking about regard the difference between funny and silly. The line "Only Nixon could go to China" is funny.

    "The Undiscovered Country"

    Spock: "The quote clearly refers to the fear of death."

    Gorkon: "But do you not see that it is also a metaphor concerning the fear of the unknown?"

    The movie could have used this disambiguation.

    Klingons

    STVI was released after the TNG episode "Heart of Glory," yet ignored the Klingon death ritual intended to send a recently departed warrior's soul to Sto-Vo-Kor which was established in that episode. In the STVI novelization, the ritual is started, but Azetbur puts a stop to it. I imagine it was left out of the movie so as "not to confuse the casual fan."

    Brigadier Kerla and Azetbur have a romantic relationship (which I don't recall from the movie version).

    General Korrd (from STV) is also a character in the STVI novelization

    Sherlock Holmes

    Spock's line about "an ancestor of mine" is present in the novelization with no explanation or clarification whatsoever.

  • Misc.

    In the novelization, Janice Rand awakens Sulu in his cabin with a message from Starfleet. In the movie, it is a male yeoman. When I saw it in the theater, the audience erupted in applause. I still have no idea why.

    Carol regains consciousness after Kirk and McCoy have been sentenced to Rura Penthe. 3½ pages. (She is mentioned again at the end.)

    Klingon Sentinel Kesla of Mortagh Outpost Three (which the Enterprise must pass) gets a backstory in the novelization.

    It is explained that "an emergency supply of viridium patches was kept on the bridge for those occasions when haste prohibited stopping by sickbay for subcutaneous transponders."

    And now the 600 lb. mugato in the transporter room...

    The Betrayal of Saavik/Valeris

    "Internally [Spock] experienced a curiously sharp bitterness that verged on physical pain. He controlled it, but did not repress it. So this was betrayal."

    Leonard Nimoy said in I Am Spock that there were second thoughts about casting a popular, established character as a villain. I have also read elsewhere [citation needed] that Gene Roddenberry himself nixed the idea of Saavik being one of the conspirators. In the movie, Spock forced the information from Valeris's mind, but in the novelization, he (meantally) asked for, and was granted, permission. That's probably a leftover from when Saavik was a going to be a character in STVI... and may account for why Spock took so long to marry her (if, in fact, he did), come to think of it. Spock was certainly upset, but as a fan, my reaction was: "Eh." Valeris was little more than a glorified redshirt to me, and the betrayal would have been much more impactful if it had been committed by Saavik. Lost opportunity there. And what did the franchise do with Saavik after that, anyway? Nuthin'.

    ...at least not in the movies or on TV. Comics, though, is another matter. I am reminded of "A Question of Loyalty" from Star Trek Special #2 (1994). I remembered this as a character study comparing and contrasting Saavik and Valeris. The stardate is 9481.1 (placing it just prior to STVI). The Enterprise is carrying 14 third year cadets from Starfleet Academy on the annual training cruise for officer candidates. One of them is Valeris, and their supervisor is Lt. Saavik. Not only do we get to see Valeris interract with Saavik, but with each of the senior staff as well, plus we get to see Saavik interract with Spock. It is in this story that Spock reccommends Saavik to take his place, but she chooses to leave the Enterprise instead. No, it's not canon, but I wish it was. 

    I also re-watched "Cause and Effect." Captain Bateson tells Picard that he thinks the year is 2278. That's four years before STII in the timeline reflected in the movies, seven years before that of the novelizations. So given that, Saavik couldn't have been on the Bozeman. 

    NOTE to Rob: There is little difference between Vulcans and Romulans genetically; the difference is cultrual. If Saavik is 139 years old circa 2404, she'd probably look about half that age in human terms, say pushing 70.

    • In the movie, it is a male yeoman. When I saw it in the theater, the audience erupted in applause. I still have no idea why.

      The male yeoman was portrayed by Christian Slater, who  was a big deal at the time, as I recall.. I think that I would have seen him in Heathers (1989).
      31298511857?profile=RESIZE_400x

    • THANK YOU!  5DyBPWx.gif

      A 35 year mystery solved!

       

    • From  what I've read, Slater was a huge Trekfan,and got the part because his mother was the casting director for the film.  If you look at the scene, he's in shadow for most of it  - it's very much not an "Oh Look, it's William Holden!" kind of thing. I remember picking up on it becuse of that distinctive voice of his.

    • "Oh, look, it's William Holden!" I'd forgotten how funny this was.

    • Thanks, Jeff. Pushing 70 seems accurate for how Saavik is shown in the comic. 

  • In STVI, I didn’t recognize him because I’m not good with faces, but IMDB tells me that he was communications officer, not yeoman.

    Christian Slater first got noticed as the younger brother of the title character in The Legend of Billie Jean (1985). Billie Jean was played by Helen Slater (no relation, the first Supergirl). I may not have been the target audience, but I greatly enjoyed the rebellious spirit of both characters. Anyone who liked Heathers would probably like this movie.

    With her brother falsely accused of attempted murder, a blonde Texas teenage stunner---victim herself of attempted assault---becomes a famous outlaw martyr, as both of them run away with friends, and try to clear their names.

  • STAR TREK: GENERATIONS

    OIP.KWsyFJ6zzPUffoyqkE6LXAHaMT?w=193&h=322&c=7&r=0&o=7&pid=1.7&rm=3

    By the time of STVII, paperback novelizations of all stripes were on their way out, yet ones for Star Trek movies (and certain key episodes, such as "All Good Things") would be released in hardcover. The novelization of Generations, like those of STV & VI before it, was written by J.M. Dillard. The book was split between sections set in the 23rd and 24th centuries, but unlike the movie (in which the opening scene lasted 18 minutes), the "classic" section of the book took up a third of the story and spanned five chapters.

    ONE

    The last night aboard the Enterprise, soon after the "Khitomer mission." Spock and McCoy stop off at Kirk's cabin on their way to the traditional firewatch party. They all have gifts for each other. McCoy gives a bottle of Saurian brandy to both; Spock gives Kirk a sextant, and McCoy a Vulcan mandala; Kirk gives Spock a copy of Horatio Hornblower, and McCoy his antique mantle clock. Kirk has proposed to Carol Marcus, but she turned him down (although she does offer him a job).

    TWO

    A year passes. The day before the Enterprise-B is to launch, Spock, McCoy, Uhura and Sulu are all unavailable for the christening ceremony. Spock has relocated to Vulcan and is involved with a diplomnatic mission from which he could not free hinself, and McCoy is attending his granddaughter's graduation from the Vulcan Science Academy. Uhura is teaching at the Academy but is currently on vacation, and Sulu is on a mission in command of the Excelsior. Chekov has left the service. He tried to reignite his romance with Irina Galliulin (see "The Way to Eden"), but she had moved on with her life. Scotty has also retired and is living in Scotland with his sister's family, writing a spate of articles for engineering journals and playing the role of doting uncle. And, as the chapter opens, Kirk is attempting his first orbital skydiving jump. If you've read the comic book adaptation, this is the first scene. The scene had been filmed for the movie, but was left out of the final cut (although it is available as a "deleted scene" on the DVD). Scott and Chekov are waiting for him on the ground. Kirk doesn't want to attend the ceremony, but the other two know he will. 

    The rest of the chapter is taken directly from the movie, with additional details added. But it is left to the comics to redeem Captain Herriman from his somewhat inauspicious debut as captain of the Enterprise (another non-canon story I wish was canon).

    988843.jpg

    Similarly, Demora Sulu is given more depth in Peter David's paperback The Captain's Daughter.

    OIP.d52RBXGp62Se4Yhegh9gygHaMb?w=132&h=180&c=7&r=0&o=7&pid=1.7&rm=3

    Given the timeline, Demora Sulu would have been born sometime between TMP and STII.

    THREE

    The rescue of the Lakul; Sorin's backstory; Kirk blown into space.

    FOUR

    Immediate aftermath: "Was anyone in there?" - "Aye..."

    FIVE

    Pavel Chekov notifies Hikaru Sulu of Kirk's death. He also told Spock, while Scott informed Uhura and Kirk's nephew (although the latter three were not detailed in the novelization). It doesn't mention who told McCoy. The most poignant scene is between Spock and McCoy when they meet privately before Kirk's memorial service.

    And thus, with the death of Captain James T. Kirk, Star Trek comes to an end.

This reply was deleted.