Report what comic books you have read today--and tell us a little something about it while you're here!

Views: 55913

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I picked up the hardback collection of The Filth, a 2004 13-issue Vertigo limited series by Grant Morrison and Chris Weston (pencils) and Gary Erskine (inks). So far I've read the first two chapters and have found it beautifully rendered and utterly incomprehensible. This one might go back to the library before I read it all.

I got far more enjoyment out of Sugar & Spike: Metahuman Investigations. This is a collection of stories from the anthology book Legends of Tomorrow.

Here, the adorable tykes from the old Sheldon Mayer humor comic are all growed up, and are working as private investigators, although they are more like retrieval experts. Each story has them recovering something for a big-name superhero, something from the Silver Age that might be embarrassing to be revealed in modern times.

For example, the first tale has them hired by Alfred to recover Batman's costumes from "The Rainbow Batman" story in Detective Comics (Volume 1) #241 (March 1957). Another deals with Wonder Woman's almost-wedding in "I Married a Monster," Wonder Woman (Volume 1) #155 (July 1965). And so on. Good, clean fun by Keith Giffen, with Bilquis Evely on art and Ivan Plascencia doing colors.

I don't for a minute believe that Kirkman simply "ran out of ideas." the TV show is the cash cow, not the comic book. At this point, the comic has diverged so far from the direction of the show (and vice versa) that, more than likely, it's more trouble than it's worth. My theory is the comic simply serves as a distraction to the task of writing the TV show. Better to cancel on and concentrate on the other. To the extent that Kirkman no longer has to maintain an increasingly diverse timeline, what he said is true. That's my theory, anyway.
Detective 445 said:

Walking Dead #193

Surprise!  This is the final issue.  A decent story but not exactly the big finish I would have liked to see.  Events in the last couple of issues were hinting that this was probably coming, but I don't follow Bleeding Cool and the like too closely so it still caught me a bit off guard.

Kirkman left plenty of doors open but claims that he just ran out of ideas. Oh well,,, at least the TV show will be less predictable now.

Jeff of Earth-J said:

I don't for a minute believe that Kirkman simply "ran out of ideas."

Yeah, I think he probably could have continued to crank out stories if there was a compelling reason for him to do it. On the other hand, he was starting to repeat himself a little bit. The most recent arc had the group encountering a new settlement which was being run by a questionable governor. And the attempt to add an "edgy" new fan favorite character (Princess)" seemed a bit contrived.

MMW DAREDEVIL V9: This volume (reprinting #85-96) is all Gerry Conway and Gene Colan. Also, Tom Palmer inked 10 of the 12 issues.) I hadn’t recalled that Karen Page hung around so long (in the series) after she left Nelson & Murdock for Hollywood. Knowing what will happen later casts her manager in an entirely different light. It wasn’t intended, but it certainly can be read that way. In addition to teaming up with the Black Widow, the stories in this volume are remembered for moving Daredevil to San Francisco. Among the villains are Electro (with a new mask which never made it to the cover), Killgrave, the Gladiator, Ox, Man-Bull and the third Mr. Fear.

SQUADRON SUPREME: I read the entire 2015-16 series to complement the “Invaders” discussion.

MASTER OF KUNG FU: I’m still working my way through the first volume for the second time. Jack Abel inks Paul Gulacy in some of these stories. I’ve read Abel-inked backissues three times in the past few weeks: MoKF, Daredevil and Avengers. Synchronicity!

MONSTERS, v2: I haven’t mentioned it since I looked at volume one, but all of the stories in these volumes are ordered by assignment number, so they are presented in the order they were commissioned, not necessarily the order they were printed.

ULTRAMAN: I’m up to volume five of the manga.

SQUADRON SUPREME (2015) #1: “Lo, there came a time when realities fell…” states the intro page of Squadron Supreme #1, against the backdrop of a planet exploding and the caption “8 MONTHS LATER.” I thought that was a reference to the recent Secret Wars mini-seriees, but after spending some time on Wikipedia, I’m not so sure. Issue #1 begins in medias res with no footnote, no editorial introduction, no nuthin’… a deficit AFAIAC. At the end of the issue, where there should be introductory editorial material, there’s a full page panel of the next issue’s cover and the smarmy caption “Do you want to know what happens next?” No, butt-munch. I want to know what happened first. If anyone knows, please fill me in (in 25 words or less) or just direct me to the source of the exploding planet.

From what I remember, this Squad was composed of survivors of various worlds that were destroyed in the Incursion Event that led to Secret Wars. 

Oh... the trade collection for this series starts off with Avengers #0 from 2015 so some of the context you're looking for might be provided in that story.  (Although I can't guarantee it)

That sounds familiar, actually.

Detective 445 said:

From what I remember, this Squad was composed of survivors of various worlds that were destroyed in the Incursion Event that led to Secret Wars. 

Oh... the trade collection for this series starts off with Avengers #0 from 2015 so some of the context you're looking for might be provided in that story.  (Although I can't guarantee it)

Thanks, guys.

Okay, “the Incursion Event that led to Secret Wars.” According to Wikipedia: “Although they are forced to destroy the other Earth to protect their own, the Illuminati resolve to continue protecting their Earth from such events, only for Namor to detonate an anti-matter device to destroy another Earth when the others could not bring themselves to do it” with a footnote referencing New Avengers v3 #21 (September 2014). That sounds like it: issue #21 of the 2013 series of New Avengers. I previously assumed it happened in Secret Wars.

I generally find Wikipedia a useful tool for identifying sources. What I find confusing is Marvel’s penchant for constantly restarting series with “new number ones.” I refer to a multi-issue story as a storyline, whereas most companies and fans call that a story arc. I consider a story arc to comprise several individual storylines which contribute to a common theme. Whenever Marvel restarts a series at #1 after only a year or two, that’s what I refer to as an arc.

But I digress.

I’ll check tomorrow to see if my LCS has New Avengers v3 #21 in stock.

I spoke about Namor's crimes here!

And given the events of the current Avengers and Invaders, history is repeating itself!

“Are there enough "It, the Living Colossus" stories for a collection?”


“I wonder… But I don't wonder enough to look them up.”

No problem. I’ve gotcha covered.

Tales of Suspense #14
Tales of Suspense #20
Astonishing Tales #21-24
The Incredible Hulk #244
Wonderman Annual #2
Marvel Comics Presents #169
Avengers Two: Wonder Man & the Beast #2-3

There were the two initial Lee/Kirby appearances, followed by the Isabella/Ayers run. Then “It” was pounded to dust by Stephen Grant and Carmine Infantino. But that didn't stop Colussus from appearing after that in the remaining four comics listed above. There are other more recent appearances as well, but those are the ones I was thinking of and the only ones I’m interested in.

“I spoke about Namor's crimes here!”

Ah, yes. I remember seeing that thread. I was tangentially aware of these events while they were happening but, to be honest, because Namor’s genocide doesn’t fit in my personal canon (a.k.a. “Earth-J”), I avoided the discussion. But Namor is one of my all-time favorite characters, and my interest has circled back around due to the current Invaders series. To tell the truth, I am ambivalent about letting these events stand vs. pressing the reset button yet again.

Re: Walking Dead 193.

I take Kirkman at his word. He says he had ideas he could have used to extend the story, but none of them were the sort of ideas that would make it worth extending the story for. The ideas he had didn't earn their place. I think that's different than "running out of ideas"...but it's also a different reason than cutting the book to spend more time with the TV show. If his time with the TV show was so important, he wouldn't have introduced Oblivion Song and Die Die Die in the past few years, and he'd probably be cutting one of those instead.

In his letter, he alludes to not wanting to take up more of Charlie Adlard's time if the story didn't warrant it. Adlard is likely gearing up for a great post-Walking Dead career, as the artist of one of the most popular modern comics ever. I think, more than anything else, he probably wants to let Adlard branch out creatively; Kirkman has had many creative outlets over this last decade; Adlard's pretty much only had the one. 

Reply to Discussion



No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.









© 2021   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service