From the Archives: Deck Log Entry # 15 Blackhawk (Part 5) . . . and Out!

In the summer of 1968, DC pulled the plug on Blackhawk. Following the two remaining issues already in production, the title would be seen no more. Editor George Kashdan would be seen no more, as well. DC fired him in April.

To oversee the last two issues of Blackhawk, DC installed former Charlton Comics editor Dick Giordano. Giordano had been a Blackhawk fan since its days in Military Comics, and he decided not to let the title die without putting up a fight. He opted for a dramatic shift of direction. On other DC titles he edited, Giordano also instituted sea changes, but those were done with the notion of playing toward modern concerns. With Blackhawk, he wanted just the reverse: he intended to return to yesteryear. Specifically, to restore the Magnificent 7’s original concept, as a paramilitary band of adventurers, operating in the real world, or at least as much of the real world as comics would let him get away with.

Anyway, he had nothing to lose in trying.

Giordano had his premise. Now he had to give it words and art. In one of the more classic stories of “How I Broke into Comics”, Giordano found just the plotline he needed in an unsolicited Blackhawk script submitted by a fan. The fan was Marv Wolfman. Dismayed by the format of “the New Blackhawk Era”, Wolfman had written a script designed to wipe out all traces of the super-hero Blackhawks and return them to their roots.

Wolfman had sent his script to George Kashdan a year before. Giordano found the mailing envelope containing Wolfman’s story in a drawer in Kashdan’s desk. The envelope had never been opened, its contents never read.

Giordano opened the envelope---and he liked what he found inside. It was just the kind of thing he wanted to do with Blackhawk. Wolfman’s writing was a little rough around the edges though, so Giordano gave it to Bob Haney for some polishing.

With that out of the way, Giordano now needed an artist. Dick Dillin had been moved over to Justice League of America, and Chuck Cuidera had retired. Then Giordano got an inspiration: since he was returning the Blackhawks to their glory days, why not get the artist most responsible for them---Reed Crandall. Giordano contacted Crandall, who initially seemed interested, but it didn’t work out. With less than two weeks until the next issue of Blackhawk was due to the printers, that opened the door for Pat Boyette.

In an interview appearing in Comic Book Artist # 1 (Spring, 1998), Giordano provided a bit more detail:

I went to the source: Reed Crandall. I never met the man but I called him on the phone and asked him if he'd like to finish off two issues of Blackhawk. Either we'll go out in style or maybe revive it if we can get something interesting happening. He said, "Yeah, I'd love to do that." So I sent him a script and never heard from him again. I guess the script wasn't to his liking and he was semi-retired anyway. So when we got close to the deadline, I called Crandall (who lived in Kansas) and asked his mother to please have him mail the script to Pat Boyette who lived in Texas, the closest artist I could find---this was all before Federal Express. I called Pat and told him that he could do whatever he wanted with the two issues because we were dead before we started. He did a nice job.


Giordano had worked with Pat Boyette at Charlton and knew the artist was capable of a quick turn-around on assignments. Just how fast Boyette got the art for Blackhawk # 242 back to Giordano is the stuff of minor legend. Boyette pencilled, inked, and lettered the 23-page story and the cover in seven, eight, nine, or ten days (depending on who is telling the tale).

Blackhawk # 242 got to the printers in plenty of time, and from there, to the hands of the readers---who got quite a surprise, starting with the first page of “My Brother---My Enemy!”


The story opened the only way it could, if Giordano wanted to return the Black Knights to their roots---by wiping G.E.O.R.G.E. off the face of the Earth. Literally. By page two, the secret G.E.O.R.G.E. installation outside of Washington, D.C., along with all of its personnel---including, presumably (and hopefully), Mr. Delta---was blown sky-high by thermite bombs. The Blackhawks, vacationing, discover this when Chuck is unable to raise the super-secret spy agency on its private radio channel. They rush back to Washington.


Standing with his men before the smoking crater that was once G.E.O.R.G.E. headquarters, Blackhawk speaks the words that fans fervently desired to hear: “ . . . Our New Era costumes were wiped out with G.E.O.R.G.E.! Hail and farewell, Leaper, Golden Centurion, M’sieu Machine, Weapons Master, and all the rest!”


From film found in a motion-picture camera deliberately left behind, the Blackhawks discover that the hand responsible for the destruction of G.E.O.R.G.E. is a terrorist group known as “Those United for Destruction”. The on-camera spokesman is their leader, a man wearing an iron mask and a sabre in place of a right arm---Black Mask!


Black Mask issues a challenge to the Black Knights, who respond by reporting to a government storage depot where they dig their old leather uniforms out of mothballs. “Okay, team,” declares Blackhawk, “we’re back where we started a thousand adventures ago. Let’s show this Black Mask what the Blackhawks are made of . . . .”


The action kicks into high gear at this point. It starts with a man-to-man confrontation between Blackhawk and Black Mask---which brings a stunning revelation. It ends with the Black Knights having to assault their old headquarters, Blackhawk Island---not seen since Blackhawk # 229 (Feb., 1967)---and meet Those United for Destruction in full combat.


The story is pure old-style Blackhawk. In the climactic confrontation with the terrorists, the team is loaded for bear. They bring sub-machine guns, hand grenades, commando knives, and their standard .45’s, and they use them, too. Lethal stakes were set when G.E.O.R.G.E. was blasted off the face of the earth, and this sense of deadly warfare maintains throughout the story. This is no traditional comic-book battle, where nobody dies. Though only a few pages long, and most of them spent fighting the War Wheel, when the Blackhawks finally clash with the terrorist band, it is pitched and bloody, indeed.


In that, Wolfman and Haney’s story was successful in evoking the flavour of the World War II Blackhawk stories. While it can be presumed that Wolfman provided the basic plot developments and Haney smoothed the transitions, it is difficult to pinpoint where one writer left off and the other took over. One notable distinction was the dialogue. While it was not quite a piquant as Arnold Drake’s, it was sharper than what had come since Drake.


If a die-hard Blackhawk fan had any complaint about “My Brother---My Enemy!” (and it is hard to conceive that there could be anyone displeased over dropping the super-hero Blackhawks), it was that Blackhawk was given yet a third origin, one that had no connexion to either of the two earlier ones.


As Wolfman (and I have to believe it was his doing) would have it, Blackhawk, before becoming Blackhawk, was Bart Hawk, a pilot in the U.S. Army-Air Forces during World War II. Hawk and his younger brother, Jack, also a flyer in the same squadron, are assigned to pilot drones loaded with T.N.T., aim them at Nazi heavy water factory, and bail out before detonation. As they near the factory, the bombers ferrying the drones come under heavy attack from Luftwaffe fighters. The bomber carrying Jack’s drone releases it early and it distracts the German fighter planes.


Bart Hawk’s drone is released on target, and he bails out as the explosive-laden ship scores a direct hit on the factory. His kid brother’s ship, however, is riddled to pieces. Upon returning to base, Bart finds out from the commanding general that using Jack’s drone as a decoy was the plan all along, and this was deliberately kept from Bart. Enraged, Bart quits the A.A.F. and forms the Blackhawks.


I have a couple of problems with this version of Blackhawk’s origin---apart from the big one in that it completely contradicts what the readers had been told before. First, a serviceman didn’t just “quit” the Army during World War II. “The duration plus six months” was in effect, and if Bart had declared his intention to leave the service, he would have been clamped in irons and sent to court-martial.


Second, I’ve never been comfortable with giving Blackhawk a real name. Never revealing his real name was one of those conceits that added to his mystique, much in the same way that the Phantom’s face was never openly revealed.


Once one got past the shock of not seeing Dillin and Cuidera draw Blackhawk, it wasn’t that difficult to adjust to Pat Boyette’s artwork. Though less detailed, Boyette shared with Bruno Premiani a strong sense of realistic composition (though, like Premiani, Boyette’s action scenes looked a bit static). In addition, Boyette brought a cinematic flair to his panel composition.


On the debit side of the ledger, Boyette did not devote a great deal of effort in distinguishing the individual Blackhawks’ faces, something Dillin did, even in his roughest work. Hair colour was pretty much the only way the reader could pick one Boyette Blackhawk out from another, and that was not the easiest of observations, given that, most of the time, the Black Knights wore hats. Blackhawk himself was the only character to get any real “face” time, and Boyette had a tendency to make him resemble actor Jack Lord.


No doubt part of the reason for the lack of distinction in the Blackhawks’ faces came from the fact that Boyette’s inking on Blackhawk # 242 is noticeably muddy, probably because it was a rush effort. But the heavy blacks obscured detail.


Despite the criticisms, there was no doubt that this was the finest Blackhawk story seen in years, at least as far as the old-time fans were concerned. Once again, the Magnificent 7 were behaving like the grizzled WWII vets they were, displaying confidence gained through experience. Added to this was an undercurrent of emotional drama, both in the utter destruction of G.E.O.R.G.E. and in the true identity of Black Mask.
Best of all, there were no science-fiction elements at all. This was real-world adventure.


And, if anything, the story that appeared in what would be the last Silver-Age issue of Blackhawk was even better.




“Mission Incredible”, from Blackhawk # 243 (Oct.-Nov., 1968) is one of my favourite “hidden gem” tales. Following on the heels of their victory over Black Mask, the Blackhawks receive a request from the U.S. government to rescue a little girl from a Soviet prison and bring her to the safety of the West. What makes this girl, Anya, so important is that her scientist father was killed by the Soviets, rather than reveal to them the formula for his latest discovery. Before his death, he taught Anya the formula and instructed her to reveal it to no-one but Blackhawk.


Instead of launching a full-force assault on the Soviet prison, Blackhawk puts together a plan in which each member of the team, working individually, rescues the little girl and relays her from one Blackhawk to another, across Europe and, ultimately, to America. After “Uncle” Hendrickson frees Anya from the prison, she is handed off to “Uncle” Stan in the Alps, and from there to “Uncle” André in Turkey, to “Uncle” Chop-Chop in Venice, to “Uncle” Olaf on board a tramp steamer, to “Uncle” Chuck in London, and finally, to Blackhawk, in the middle of the Atlantic aboard the team’s mini-sub. All the while, each Black Knight has to outwit K.G.B. agents hot on the girl’s trail.


Four years earlier, Bob Haney wrote the exceptional "Origin of Chop-Chop" tale. Here again, he really delivers a top-drawer Blackhawk effort. The plot divides the story into vignettes, affording each team member a chance to shine. As to be expected, each Blackhawk relies on his special talents, but unlike earlier tales, this isn’t the sole emphasis to distinguish them in solo action.


Haney grafts identifiable personalities onto the individual Blackhawks. Hendrickson is avuncular, even in the heat of fighting off the Soviet soldiers. Stan, armed only with a knife, stoically kills an attacking bear, his great strength treated as a given. Chuck is serious-minded and easily irritated by setbacks in carrying out his leg of the mission. And while the other Blackhawks experience physical hardship in carrying out their assignments, André is found enjoying the lap of luxury in Turkey, by suavely posing as an army general.


But it’s Haney’s dialogue which really makes these sequences ring. The Blackhawks talk like men accustomed to being in harm’s way, with casual directness and wry commentary. Also in evidence are small inside references that any group of men who had worked together for so long would share. If I didn’t know better, I’d swear that Arnold Drake wrote it.


Even the little girl, Anya, gets her share of good lines. Serving as something of a Greek chorus, she voices her observations without cutesy kiddie talk or the wiseacre sarcasm of television moppets. She’s a perfectly natural little girl thrust into a bizarre situation.


As for the art, all of Pat Boyette’s strengths are in evidence, but the muddiness that marred his inking on the previous issue is not. The lines are strong and the blacks subdued. This time, the individual Black Knights have clearly distinguishable features.

Dick Giordano’s success at returning the Magnificent 7 to their basics makes it an especial pity that the cancellation of the title was a done deal. The two issues under his leadership were easily the best Blackhawk stories to see print since their Quality Comics days, even eclipsing Boltinoff and Drake’s brief shining moment.


At least, the Blackhawks could once again hold their heads high as they made that final flight from the Silver Age to comic-book limbo.


HAWKKKKK-AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!

Views: 306

Comment by Philip Portelli on July 12, 2010 at 8:01pm
These were fine send-offs for comics' first Dark Knights. Will you be commenting on the hip 70s revival?
Comment by Figserello on July 12, 2010 at 10:07pm
Great series of posts. Covering 135 issues, and over a decade of DC comics, which is good going.

Are you taking requests? Any chance of some blogs on Doom Patrol and Animal Man?

From your concentration on the 'realistic' issues of Blackhawks, I'm guessing that they were maybe too weird for your tastes at the time, Commander? But then again, you speak highly of Premiani and Drake in these posts, so...

The second Showcase of Doom Patrol is due out in August and I've just noticed that it brings the story up to issue 121, which was the final Silver Age story, so maybe it would be a good time for a retrospective of the whole run. I'd love to read your thoughts on it.

I know Animal Man was extremely obscure and only ran in a few issues, but the same could be said for that magician guy that you did the blog on, who died and came back as a completely different magician guy. He was probably the most obscure character I've ever read about. Sorry I can't rememebr his name.
Comment by Commander Benson on July 13, 2010 at 1:14am
Thanks for the kind words, fellows.

Even though I have the complete run of the 1976-7 revival Blackhawk series, Mr. Portelli, I won't be looking at it. My column covers only the Silver Age. Occasionally, one of my articles will mention something before or after that period---if it, somehow, emphisises the Silver-Age aspect (such as when I began my Blackhawk series with its Golden-Age roots to show how far the character had declined under DC's handling in the late '50's). But generally, I stay within the 1956-68 borders.

Figserello, the Doom Patrol has been on my list of article possibilities for some time. I actually enjoyed the series---at least the first couple of years. (My personal feeling is that it jumped the shark when Mento and Beast Boy were introduced.) And I have all of the Silver-Age issues to reference.

I hadn't planned on covering the DP's entire run, as I did with the Blackhawks. But I was definitely looking at doing an entry for the Patrol under my "Death in the Silver-Age" sub-heading. And that could very well run into more than one part, as did my look at the death of Red Ryan in Challengers of the Unknown.

Animal Man is another good idea. My Mark Merlin/Prince Ra-Man article also fell under "Death in the Silver Age", but I have done retrospectives of obscure Silver-Age characters before---e.g., Ultra, the Multi-Alien. The problem is, though, that I don't have all of Animal Man's Silver-Age appearances.

I've already got the next new article planned out, but I think you may be seeing something on the Doom Patrol pretty soon.
Comment by Figserello on July 13, 2010 at 1:38am
Cool! Looking forward to it. Any angle would be good. They are great comics, but they aren't studied in the same depth as Marvel's comics of the same time. I read them 'in parallel with' Drake's issues of X-men and they were far superior.

I'm really lookingforward to reading the rest of Drake's DP run in August. I'm not normally in a rush to get Showcases, but this one's different.

Ah, Ra-man! He appeared in Grant Morrison's Seven Soldiers of Victory, but I read it after reading your piece on Merlin/Ra-man and didn't realise they were the same guy.

Maybe there is still a piece to be written on the Animal man appearances you do have? It's up to you, of course.
Comment by Randy Jackson on July 13, 2010 at 11:16pm
I think I meant to post this earlier--or thought that I had--but about 9-12 months ago I read Showcase Presents: Blackhawk and really thought it was exceptionally awful. I'm pretty sure that was the late 50's era, and the stories were less interesting than watching paint dry.
Comment by Figserello on July 13, 2010 at 11:22pm
Yeah, I'd be interested in reading the ones the Commander highlighted, but we'd have a long wait. He skipped over about 4 showcases worth of stories in a few sentences early on - probably justifiably. Late 50's/early 60's sci-fi era stories.
Comment by Commander Benson on July 13, 2010 at 11:47pm
"[Commander Benson] skipped over about 4 Showcases worth of stories in a few sentences early on---probably justifiably."

Yep, I swept up all of DC's Blackhawk output from '57 to '64 with one broom in the first part. And as you guessed, Figserello---justifiably.

As the esteemed Mr. Jackson noted, those seven years of Blackhawk tales are purely routine plots, running from plot point to plot point, with nothing to make them distinctive. Most of them are the weird transformation/BEM/alien stories. The only stories that are worth noting are the two which introduce Lady Blackhawk and then win her her honorary Black Knight status.

So, even though it was a seven-year-period, I didn't see much point in wasting a lot of copy on it.
Comment by Figserello on July 14, 2010 at 12:05am
Thinking about the reprint policy for these, Showcases in particular... (Going waay off topic.)

I wonder if DC should have thought about reprinting the later stories of some of these series first? Say Showcase Presents: Green Lantern Vol 3, or Showcase Presents: Flash Vol 2 before the vol 1 of them. A lot of SA DC series don't really get their feet under them until 30 or 50 issues in...

As it is, people will sample the first Showcase volume of stuff like the Blackhawks and decide they were all rubbish, or the sales will be too low for future volumes to be viable.

For my part, I waited until the second volume of Showcase World's Finest before jumping in.
Comment by Luke Blanchard on July 14, 2010 at 1:40am
I often think these kinds of collections could use a text page explaining some of the publishing context.
Comment by Luke Blanchard on July 14, 2010 at 2:02am
Some of DC's titles in the 50s/60s were bimonthlies, some monthlies, and some appeared eight times a year, so the Showcases cover different periods of time. One might have expected DC to have put Blackhawk on an eight-times-a-year schedule, like Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman, but instead it kept it monthly. (I think I've read DC initially leased the feature: perhaps there was something in the agreement about it.) So the Showcase only covers issues cover-dated for 1957-1958.

I'd be interested in hearing if either of you gents liked the stories from the first couple of issues more. It's said to be the case they were prepared while the title was still at Quality.

Comment

You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!

Join Captain Comics

Welcome!

No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.

SOME ESSENTIALS:

RULES OF THE ROUND TABLE

MODERATORS

SMILIES FOLDER

TIPS ON USING THE BOARD

FOLLOW US:

OUR COLUMNISTS:

Groups

© 2019   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service