I thought it would be fun to talk about the comic books on my bookshelf. Like a lot of comic book fans, I have a bookshelf full to overflowing of original graphic novels and trade paperback collections.

Abe Sapien Vol. 1 and BPRD Vol. 1-12

Although I primarily buy single issues (I refuse to use the pejorative term “floppies”), there are a few series that I read as trades. At the top of that list is the Hellboy spin-off BPRD. The Bureau of Paranormal Research and Development has great characters and compelling adventures of its own. I especially enjoyed the way it developed into an ongoing series even though it’s still solicited as a series of mini-series. There’s more room for sub-plots, character development and an overarching narrative.

Abe Sapien is one of the best characters of the past 20 years. He stole the show in the
second Hellboy movie and his solo adventures in comics are well worth reading too.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer Omnibus Vol. 1-7

I really like the way that Dark Horse approached their big Buffy collection. They
eschewed reprinting the stories in publication order. Instead, they chose to reprint the comics in the fictional chronology of the series. That means we get some great tales at the outset featuring stories set in the past for Buffy, Spike and the rest of the crew. It also makes for a better mix of stories as long arcs and short stories, and solo features and ensemble pieces alternate. It makes for a better blend of quality (the initial ongoing series took a little while to get really good). Plus, it’s fun to see Dawn written into some of Buffy’s earliest adventures.

I should mention that technically only volumes 1-6 are on my bookshelf. Anacoqui has volume 7 in a “to-be-read-someday” pile on her bookshelf.

The Chronicles of Conan Vol. 1-14

Conan is one of the first older series that I collected exclusively through trade. I
had always heard great things about it but it seemed way too intimidating (and cost-prohibitive) to try buying all of the back issues. Dark Horse’s reprint collection was perfect. I bought the first volume in 2003. I loved the stories, the Barry Windsor-Smith art and the Roy Thomas retrospectives. I eagerly awaited each successive volume, and waited in trepidation when it looked the series might be cancelled (there was an unexplained delay of a year between volumes 10 and 11). After 14 volumes, I mostly had my fill and decided to walk away with Roy Thomas (they’re now up to volume 20).

The Savage Sword of Conan Vol. 1-5

These 500-page black-and-white monsters are a satisfying chunk of story. However, the simultaneous publishing of Savage Sword “phonebooks” and Chronicles may explain why I got burned out on Conan and ready to leave with Roy.

MySpace DHP Vol. 1

I’m funny that way. I rarely read webcomics. But I have no problem buying collections of comics previously available on the web for free. Dark Horse’s MySpace collections
are a wonderful anthology featuring characters from their diverse line as well as entirely new concepts. They’ve introduced me to Usagi Yojimbo, delighted me with Dr. Horrible and impressed me with so much more. Volume 1 is on my shelf. 2 and 3 are on Ana’s (a recurring theme). However, I’m a little behind and haven’t yet bought volumes 4 and 5.

Hellboy Volume 1-5, 8-10

Who says that movies can’t bring new readers to comics- or, at least, to a series? The first Hellboy comic I bought was a $1 reprint of “The Body” that came out with the first Hellboy movie as a promotion. I loved it. I bought a couple of the early trades and started collecting the new stories as they came out. I soon discovered that I enjoyed Hellboy a lot more in trades than in single issues. So I switched back to trades with volume 8.

Spyboy Vol. 1-5 and Young Justice

I started buying this Peter David/Pop Mhan vehicle just as it was being canceled. I loved the blend of action and humor. I loved the characters and the use of chibis (Japanese style animated avatars that crack jokes along the margins). And I would have switched to buying the monthly issues except it was, y’know, discontinued.

Star Wars: A Long Time Ago Vol. 1-7

I enjoyed reading the older Conans in trade form so much that I decided to take
the plunge with another classic series from the ‘70s and ‘80s: Marvel’s Star Wars.
Thankfully, Dark Horse had collected the entire series in 7 distinctive volumes. Ana bought me the first couple as a moving to Rochester present just over 3 years ago. I completed the collection in just over a year. I greatly enjoyed the series. There were some lows (Carmine Infantino had no idea how to draw Chewbacca). But there were some real highs as well right through the end with the introduction of compelling villains like Lumiya.

Classic Star Wars Vol. 1-3 and Early Adventures

These volumes collect the Star Wars newspaper strip. The first three volumes are by Al Williamson and they’re absolutely brilliant. Williamson had an incredible
eye for detail. He drew luscious landscapes, intricate spaceships and recognizable
characters. Early Adventures was drawn by another comics legend, Russ Manning, but unfortunately the strips are some of the worst Star Wars comics I’ve read in any format.

Star Wars: Clone Wars Volume 7, Darth Maul, Force Unleashed, General Grievous and Menace Revealed Omnibus

For a while, I was collecting quite a lot of Star Wars comics. Even so, I missed the occasional mini-series and had to pick it up later in a trade. Clone Wars Volume 7 collects the excellent Obsession mini-series with art by Brian Ching. It features a classic confrontation between Anakin and Obi-Wan on one side and Asajj Ventress on the other. Darth Maul and General Grievous focus on a couple of prominent villains. Force Unleashed is an original graphic novel based on the recent video game. And Menace Revealed is a big collection of issues that came out before and during Star Wars Episode I.

Umbrella Academy Vol. 1-2

I was curious about this series from the get-go, even though I wasn’t a fan of Gerard Way (the writer) or My Chemical Romance (his band)… yet. But I was cautious. Hesitant, even. I skipped the single issues. Yet I kept hearing good things about the series. Finally, I dropped down an even bigger chunk of change to buy the trade. I am so glad I did. Umbrella Academy was excellent. It featured great characters (though I always thought Kraken and Horror had their names backwards) and told an engrossing story over time. Plus, the White Violin is one of the greatest- and most visually interesting- villains I’ve ever seen. The second volume, Dallas, is just as good, though this time I intentionally waited for the trade.


One more Hellboy/BPRD spin-off to finish off the Dark Horse shelf.

Next week, on to the second shelf and DC.

Views: 114

Comment by Luke Blanchard on September 17, 2010 at 1:04pm
I only read a couple of Mary Jo Duffy's Star Wars issues, but I very much liked #80. Duffy's issues of Power Man and Iron Fist with Kerry Gamill were even better.

You've written 'Archie' for 'Al' in the newspaper strip paragraph.
Comment by Jeff of Earth-J on September 17, 2010 at 1:06pm
Random comments:

Buffy the Vampire Slayer: I really didn't like volume one. Before I even consider buying any others, though, I need to read the entire "Season Eight" after the final tpb has been collected.

Chronicles of Conan: I finally stopped buying this series, too (although I must admit I stopped reading around the same time you did.) I'll get back to it someday. I don't know if you read my reaction the the Conan newspaper strip collection on the main board, but steer clear of that one (because of bad reproduction values).

Hellboy: For a time (for a long time) I read this series from the beginning, but later dropped it during a "cutback phase." When I decided to get back into it, I couldn't figure out what I had missed. I like series that begin numbering with "1" and continue sequentially thereafter.

Star Wars Marvel Comics: I turned my nose up at these when they were on the racks, but bought the first two volumes of this series in conjunction with the reprints of Gold Key Star Trek a couple of years ago. I would have hated them in the '70s and '80s, but I find them gloriously cheesy now. I'll continue with this series sometime when I'm in the mood again.

Star Wars Newspaper Strips: I read and enjoyed these when they were first run. I bought the tpbs cheap at one of Polar Rocket's Mid-South Cons, but I haven't been in the mood the read them yet. (It Archie Goodwin and Al Williamson, BTW.)
Comment by Chris Fluit on September 17, 2010 at 3:24pm
Thanks for the catch, Luke. I was probably thinking of Archie Goodwin (who wrote some of those Star Wars comics) and slipped the wrong first name in accidentally.
Comment by Chris Fluit on September 17, 2010 at 3:27pm
Jeff, you can read the Buffy Omnibuses before reading Buffy Season Eight. They won't contain spoilers or anything.

Thanks for the Conan warning. I was kind of hoping one of the local libraries would pick up the rest of the Chronicles and Savage "phonebooks." I wouldn't mind getting a look at them but I've heard mixed reviews of the post-Thomas issues (to put it kindly) and don't want to risk my own cash.

That's another reason to read Hellboy in trades, Jeff. The trades come with numbers on them.

And Jeff nailed me on the Archie/Al goof as well. Sheesh! Ya make one mistake around here...
Comment by Cavaliere (moderator emeritus) on September 17, 2010 at 6:06pm
If it weren't for Marvel's Star Wars series, I probably wouldn't be reading comics today. It was my "gateway drug."
Comment by Travis Herrick (Modular Mod) on September 17, 2010 at 8:39pm
see I just couldn't OD on the Conan like ya'll. Small doses fellas.
Also I dont't find "floppie" to be a pejorative term. I find it to be pretty inocuous myself.
Comment by Figserello on September 18, 2010 at 6:45am
Ah, I only got a the end that this was the Dark Horse shelf. Wondering what the critereria was for this particular group.

I have all the 1st Buffy series, except in thin Titan volumes. I got most of them from remainder bookshops as they had been sold through regular bookshops at th e height of the series fame.

I'll say again that the good arcs are very satisfying and fill gaps in the TV series well. Think you'll really enjoy them Jeff.

Regarding Conan I have to agree with Travis. Conan is a brilliant character, but there is only so much his stories can do before they stop being Conan stories. And haven't they adapted some of REH's stories several times by now?

The only Dr Horrible comic I've read didn't have a patch on the 'musical'.

I've read way to little Hellboy and no BPRD (Always wondered what the intials were for, thanks.) Jeff has a point about not knowing the order to read them. The last Hellboy I read was very good entertainment, and beautifully drawn, but I can't remember anything about the plot except maybe it had Nazis in it, which probably doesn't narrow it down much.

The only Spy-Boy I have is the team-up with Young Justice, which is probably the only young Justice I have too. Good PAD fun as I recall, even though it was ten years ago.

I think I have a few of both those Star Wars collections, but I haven't read them yet. Keep hearing good things about them though.

(One reason I haven't read them is because I bought them in sealed bags 2nd hand, and when I opened them to read, it was obvious their previous owner was a smoker and the books had absorbed the stench of the noxious weed. Bleeaugh! Maybe their half-life has decreased by now. I should check.)

Umbrella Academy - Had my hand on this last visit to the Library. Should really have got it, but I had a few library books still to read on my shelf at the time.
Comment by Chris Fluit on September 18, 2010 at 10:04am
I agree with the comments about Conan being best in smaller doses. The huge 500-plus page Savage Swords were too much. The Chronicles, which contained about 10-12 issues, were just right.

(now I have to find out who's been eating my porridge and sitting in my chair)
Comment by Jeff of Earth-J on September 18, 2010 at 11:36am
Buffy: At this point I'm not worried about spoilers reading the Omnibi (I may ahve just made up that word) so much as I am interested in reading "Season Eight" in its entirety before moving "backwards."

Conan: I forgot to mention (for completeness' sake because I'm sure you know it, too, that Dark Horse has now started a separate King Conan series. I've come to the same conclusion as Chris and Travis and Figs that Conan reads best in small doses.

Star Wars newspaper: Note that Luke commented while I was writing my post; otherwise I wouldn't've nailed you a second time for the same mistake, buddy! :)
Comment by Chris Fluit on September 18, 2010 at 1:13pm
Figserello, you're right re: dr. Horrible comics. No music! However, I really liked the one-shot with billy's origin story.


You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!

Join Captain Comics


No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.









© 2020   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service