Selected Superman Stories from the Past 5 Years

831-1 I had so much fun writing about Superman for last week’s article that I thought I’d come back for another round. In the first article, I covered stories that fell between “Crisis on Infinite Earths” and “Countdown to Infinite Crisis.” This time, I’m covering Superman comics from the past 5 years when I’ve been a much more regular reader.

Action Comics #827-835 (July ’05-May ’06):
If you’re looking for a short, but excellent, run of Superman comics to collect, let me recommend this brief sojourn by Gail Simone and John Byrne. The third issue is part of the larger Sacrifice story, crossing over with the other Superman titles as well as Wonder Woman, but the rest of the run is predominantly self-contained. Even the tie-ins with Villains United and Day of Vengeance work well on their own. Plus, it’s great to see Superman fight Black Adam or become befuddled by the Spectre. The end of the run is even better than the beginning, when Simone brings two modern villains to the Superman titles: The Queen of Fables from Mark Waid’s JLA and Livewire from the Superman animated series.

Superman_650 Superman #650-653, Action Comics #837-840 (May-August 2006): Kurt Busiek, Geoff Johns and Pete Woods bring us a simply stupendous Superman story. Clark Kentslowly regains his powers. Lex Luthor gets ahold of a Kryptonian crystal. Toyman and Prankster cause trouble. And Supergirl co-stars. It’s just a great romp in which Superman starts out as the underdog before emerging as the world’s greatest hero once again by the end. And it’s chock full of rogues from Superman’s gallery of villains, from Lex Luthor to Silver Banshee to Livewire.

Action Comics #841-842 (Sept.-Nov. ’06): I like the many guest stars, from the Jason Rusch Firestorm to Busiek’s own Power Company creation Skyrocket, but this is otherwise a fairly standard kidnapped-by-an-alien superhero great escape story and the Auctioneer is basically an updated Collector.

656-1 Superman #654-658, 662-664, 667 and Annual 13 (September ‘06-January ’08):This is Kurt Busiek and Carlos Pacheco’s Superman magnum opus. Though shipping delays led to fan dissatisfaction, the story stands out as one of the best I’ve ever read and re-read. “Camelot Falls” asks questions about heroism by casting Arion, Lord of Atlantis, as a villain. Itraises issues of loyalty, as when Subjekt 17 challenges Superman’s fidelity to his adopted planet against aliens who have been mistreated. It shows the price of failure, by spending time in a possible future where survivors fight on long after Superman has been defeated. And it makes sure that victory won’t be easy, by setting Superman up against a magical foe he can’t defeat directly. Plus, Busiek introduces a wealth of new characters like Subjekt 17, Sirocco and Squad K, while mixing in a few fun guest stars like the Young Gods from New Genesis. And, of course, the Carlos Pacheco art is magnificently beautiful throughout.

846-1 Action Comics #844-846, 851 and Annual 11 (December ’06-June ’08):This is the other Superman magnum opus of 2006, I mean ’07, I mean ’08. This time, former Superman director Richard Donner, Geoff Johns and Adam Kubert provide the incredible story, as well as the infuriating delays. And, once again, taken on its own, the story stands as a classic. General Zod leads a break-out from the Phantom Zone. Superman must fight Zod, Urza, and Non as well as dozens more of Krypton’s most nefarious villains. There is also a Bizarro appearance and the problem of what to do with a kid who seems to have all of Superman’s powers. The child is the son of Urza and Zod, though Clark and Lois take him as a foster son, Christopher Kent. Besides the wonderful characters both old and new, there are also some delightful twists and extras. At one point, Superman is banished to the Phantom Zone himself, which Adam Kubert and DC render in 3-D giving it an otherworldly dimension with or without the special glasses.

660-1 Superman #660 and Action Comics #847 (March and April 2007): The incessant delays on “Camelot Falls”and the Phantom Zone story necessitated a large number of fill-in stories. Most of them aren’t worth talking about, even when worked on by luminaries like Walt Simonson or Fabian Nicieza. But two stand out in excellence and are worth discussing, even if they are very different from one another. The first, in Superman 660, is fun story by Kurt Busiek and Mike Manley told from the Prankster’s point of view. It’s a riot to see his self-justification and self-delusion, as well as the convoluted pranks he attempts to perform. The other, in Action 847, is a real tear jerker. Dwayne McDuffie and Renato Guedes bring us a story told by Jonathan Kent. With the Phantom Zone criminals rampaging, Martha fears for the life of her son. Jonathan calmly tells her the story of an inter-galactic fishing trip as a way of reminding her how super their son really is.

Superman_Vol1_675_Variant_Large Superman #674-675 (May-June 2008):After two lackluster and overly continuity-conscious trilogies (“The Third Kryptonian” and “The Insect Queen”), Busiek ended his Superman run on a high note. He does a great job of weaving several different strands into a single beautiful tapestry. He depicts Superman’s married bliss with Lois and foster son, Christopher- a relationship which was a strength throughout Busiek’s tenure. He deals with Mon-El’s plight as a captive in the Phantom Zone. He has Superman square off against pseudo-hero Paragon who claims that Superman is an impostor. He even brings in a trio of Daxamites and a Galactic Golem. Plus, the entire story is exquisitely drawn by Renato Guedes, who is just starting to establish himself as a Superman superstar.

Action Comics #865 (July 2008): Kurt Busiek told his villain story for the Prankster back in Superman 660 and now Geoff Johns takes his turn with a special Toyman tale. It’s another great job updating an older villain so that he works for the present. Plus, Jesus Merino’s picture of the wall of previous toymen was a delight to behold.

863-5 Action Comics #858-863 (December ’07-May ’08) and Action Comics #866-870 (August-December ’08): The latter half of Geoff Johns’ tenure features two grand epics: “Superman and the Legion of Super-Heroes” and “Brainiac.” Brad Meltzer and Geoff Johns had already begun the re-integration of the classic Legion into current continuity with their JLA/JSA crossover “The Lightning Saga.” In Action Comics, Johns continues the trend, this time with an actual story. Superman is launched forward into time. He meets the Legion, but he also discovers two unnerving dilemmas. His body isn’t attuned to the sun of the future with the result that his powers are weakening. Worse, Earth-Man is citing Superman’s legacy as the reason for xenophobic mandate that would banish all aliens- including the bulk of the Legion- from Earth. We know that Superman is supposed to be the strongest, most powerful hero ever. So it’s always fun to see what happens when he isn’t, and to give him a foe that he can’t beat with a punch. In this case, bigotry. Meanwhile, Johns and new artist Gary Frank do a great job of taking the classic Giffen/Levitz Legion and updating them for today’s fashion. Then, after a brief interlude (see the above entry), Geoff and Gary give us a Brainiac epic. The story is set in both the past- when Brainiac first abducts the Kryptonian city of Kandor- and the present- as Superman fights Brainiac in the sky over Earth. Once again, Johns manages to tell a story that is both classic and modern.

462710-superman678_super Superman #677-680 (August-November ’08): James Robinson takes over for Kurt Busiek (who moved to Trinity). Unfortunately, his initial story is sub-standard. It’s great that a classic Bronze Age villain like Atlas is brought into the modern day and that Krypto finally re-joins the Superman family as well. However, Robinson rotates through several point-of-view characters, none of whom are Superman. The result is that Superman feels like a guest-star in his own book. That kind of an approach can work (as with the aforementioned Prankster and Toyman stories, as well as the current “World Without a Superman” titles) but I wasn’t happy with it here. On the positive side, Renato Guedes takes over as the regular Superman artist and his work is breath-taking.

There you go. That’s my overview of the past 5 years of Superman comics,beginning with “Countdown to Infinite Crisis,” running past “One Year Later” and finishing up at the “New Krypton” crossover. I may have more to say about the “World Without a Superman” stories later, but for now, it’s time to move on to something else. Up, up and away!

Views: 100

Comment by Figserello on July 18, 2009 at 8:35am
I mentioned last time that I have a large collection of Post-Crisis Pre-Infinite Crisis Superman comics, and I try to read them in order every now and again. (I'll have filled a few gaps each time I go back.) But each time my reading project runs out of steam before I get to the Pre-Infinite Crisis comics. A pity as some of them look interesting. I mentioned For Tomorrow, for instance and I have the collected TPB of the Simone issues you mention. Someday I'll get around to them, maybe when I have to stop buying new comics!

As for the others 'Up, up and Away' is one of the best Superman stories of the past 20 years. I decided that the following issues weren't quite up to the same standard, and I couldn't justify getting them month in month out. I see that my library has most of the stories you mention above though, and I am very much looking forward to reading htem over the next few months.

Not mentioning All Star Superman - one of the best Superman stories EVAH - is a serious omission though! You should try to get your hands on it if you haven't already. It's written in a much more accessible Silver Age style than some of Morrison's other more obtuse output. #10 is a thing of beauty.
Comment by Batmatt Beyond on July 22, 2009 at 5:03pm
Yep, this period will forever be known in Batmattland as "The Time That Batmatt Preferred Superman Comics Over Batman Comics."
Comment by Figserello on July 22, 2009 at 9:24pm
Yeah, it looks to me like they have really focused on making Superman a great hero again since Infinite Crisis. 'Up, Up and Away' showed that they saw that things needed fixing at any rate.

I read the one about Jonathan's 'fishing trip'. That was a great little story. Nice that it was both a 'filler' and somewhat related to the ongoing arc. It really made you think what it would be like to be the father of this godlike being. There was a sense that Jonathan felt very small and impotent along the way in it, but he must have felt proud that all the values his son was showing, including self-sacrifice and willingness to endanger his own life - scary for a parent - were values that Clarke had got from him. Few parents get to see that so clearly.

It doesn't look like Clarke got any of the Kent pig-headedness from Jonathan though!

even though they were father and son, they didn't look very different in age. Perhaps my only complaint about this issue.

It's strange that they first de-aged Jonathan after IC and then had him die of a heart-attack! You'd think making him younger would have bolstered his health a bit!

And its probably pretty well known, but in Superman's hey-day in the 40's, Toyman was his biggest, most famous adversary, mixing it with the Kryptonian as often as Luthor did in the 60's.

I wonder what changed along the way that he fell out of favour with the writers and fans?

I've read one of the new Toyman stories too. It was great, but a writer has to be extra clever to allow him to go up against the Man of Steel and not get his ass whupped in about 3 seconds. That's his sticking point. Also he might be too 'fun' for the times we're living in. He'd be good for a light change between serious arcs though.

Quote: "...“The Lightning Saga.” In Action Comics, Johns continues the trend, this time with an actual story."

Nicely put.
Comment by Chris Fluit on July 23, 2009 at 8:50pm
Not mentioning All Star Superman - one of the best Superman stories EVAH - is a serious omission though! You should try to get your hands on it if you haven't already. It's written in a much more accessible Silver Age style than some of Morrison's other more obtuse output. #10 is a thing of beauty.

I didn't mention All-Star because I don't own it. However, I have read the first trade thanks to the library and I thought it was incredible. I'm looking forward to reading the second one later this year. The hardcover is out already but the softcover doesn't come out until this fall- I'll probably pick up both trades when it arrives.

Quote: "...“The Lightning Saga.” In Action Comics, Johns continues the trend, this time with an actual story."
Nicely put.

Comment by Figserello on July 23, 2009 at 11:14pm
Not tempted to wait for the inevitable Absolute edition and get pt II from the library in the meanwhile? It is a tome for the ages.

I'll make do with my 12 floppy copies as I've already put my money down.

BTW is it only DC that does the 'Absolute' editions or are they common to both big companies?


You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!

Join Captain Comics


No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.









© 2021   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service