The Good, the Bad and the Ugly: Wolverine’s Villains

Wolverine is unique among superhero superstars. The other big heroes (Superman, Batman, Spider-Man, etc.) all started out as solo heroes and then were added to teams like the Avengers or the Justice League of America based on their popularity. But
Wolverine started out as a member of a team. He wasn’t even the star of the team when he started. He was the foil who moved up to favorite and finally graduated to superstar status.

For that reason, Wolverine doesn’t have the same set of foes as other heroes. He doesn’t have a classic nemesis like Lex Luthor or The Joker. He doesn’t have a huge rogues’ gallery like Spider-Man. Many of his favorite antagonists are borrowed from other heroes or his home team, the Uncanny X-Men. Yet there are villains who were created to face Wolverine. And there are others who have migrated to so many of his stories that they’re now primarily associated with Wolverine.

Here are my assorted thoughts on Wolverine’s villains: the regulars, the oddities, the frenemies, the good, the bad and the ugly.

The Good

The best villains always reflect something back to the protagonist. Sometimes, they fulfill that role by being the opposite number. The Joker is chaos to Batman’s control. Lex Luthor is the brains to Superman’s brawn. Wolverine is the savage beast struggling to be civilized. Therefore, many of his best villains are those who use the veneer of civilization to cover a savage heart.

Lord Shingen is a great example of this. Lady Mariko’s father (and Logan’s prospective father-in-law) is about manners and titles. He’s respected and courteous. Where Wolverine is all rough edges, Lord Shingen is as smooth as silk. Yet Shingen’s civilized exterior hides a heart that is ruthless. He’s more bloodthirsty than Wolverine. Yet while Wolverine succumbs to an uncontrollable bloodlust, Shingen is coldly calculating in the way that he both orders and delivers death.

However, Lord Shingen isn’t alone. The resplendently dressed Matsuo Tsuyaraba has more respect for fine clothes than he does for human life. Donald Pierce is willing to throw his own humanity away in his quixotic quest to destroy those that he sees as inhuman. And the Silver Samurai displays the nobility of the samurai externally while consistently choosing the wrong side of any moral issue. Then, there’s Geist. He has old
world aristocracy. He’s also a former Nazi with a disdain for inferior races because every hero needs at least one ex-Nazi.

Sometimes, great villains fulfill that role by reflecting the hero back to himself. They’re the mirror image, the carbon copy. Sinestro’s ring has the same powers as Green Lantern’s. The Crimson Dynamo wears a suit of armor just like Iron Man. Similarly,
Wolverine faces a lot of foes with claws of fury. Most of these will be covered in the third section, “Ugly.” But a few of them fit here.

The closest carbon copy is Lady Deathstrike. She went through the same adamantium bonding process as Wolverine. Her fingers house long spikes, giving her five claws to Wolverine’s three. She has a few other cybernetic enhancements but she’s essentially what Wolverine would be if he had volunteered for the Weapon X program.

The other great mirror image is Sabretooth. Though he originally fought Power Man and Iron Fist, he has become Wolverine’s greatest villain. They are two sides of the same coin. They are former brothers in arms. They have the same healing factor and animal savagery. When Wolverine fights Sabretooth, he fights himself. At least, he fights what he would be if he wasn’t also fighting his own nature to become a better man. The clashes between Wolverine and Sabretooth are almost always classics.

The Bad

Of course, not every bad guy is going to be a good one. I mean, none of them are good. They’re all villains, after all. But some of them aren’t even good villains. They’re not interesting. They’re not fleshed out as characters with motivation and purpose. They don’t seem to have a reason to fight this hero as opposed to any other.

The first villain that comes to mind in this category is Cyber. He’s supposed to be one of

Wolverine’s opposite numbers. However, instead of having adamantium bonded to his skeleton, he has been given an adamantium skin. That should make him invulnerable. Not even Wolverine’s claws can cut him. But his personality is only skin deep (I apologize for the bad pun). He’s a random fighter and a faceless foe. Plus, his name doesn’t have anything to do with his powers.

I would also include Genesis in this category. Genesis is the one who killed Cyber and tried to use Cyber’s adamantium to restore Wolverine. Against Wolverine’s wishes, I might add. That’s a pretty pivotal part to play in Wolverine’s life. So you’d think that Genesis would be a pretty important or interesting character. Unfortunately, he’s not. His real name is Tyler Dayspring and he’s Cable’s son. But that doesn’t explain why he
has such an interest in Wolverine. There’s a reason why Trigon fights the Titans and not the Outsiders. One has a personal connection, the other does not.

Wolverine has also faced off against a few uninteresting minor villains. Roughhouse and Bloodscream come to mind. One was big and ugly. The other was pale and ugly. However, they were introduced early in Wolverine’s solo series so they keep coming
back, kind of like the Mole Man and the Fantastic Four.

The Ugly

Wolverine is a pretty scruffy fellow. He has big sideburns and wild hair that sticks out. He’s got a bit of the beast in him. And the writers like to have fun with that. Wolverine
fights a lot of beasts, a lot of monsters and a lot of ugly villains.

In his debut, he fought a mythical monster known as Wendigo. In one of his classic stories, Weapon X, he actually fought a bear. And in a great ongoing story, he fought a werewolf called the Hunter-in-Darkness. He’s fought actual wolverines, wild dingoes and dinosaurs. Wolverine is often depicted fighting the beast within. But a lot of times,
he gets to let loose and fight an actual beast, too.

Yet not every ugly villain is an animal. There are a few ugly humans, too. Some of them are ugly by accident. Some are ugly by choice. Deadpool is the classic example of the
former. Like Sabretooth (and so many others), Deadpool debuted outside of Wolverine’s title. And Deadpool has become a bit of a star in his own right, with several solo titles. But they share a connection in their common history with the Weapon X program.The disfigured Deadpool makes for a great Wolverine villain when they do tangle as Deadpool’s sense of humor plays off of Wolverine’s serious nature.

On the other hand, Ogun is ugly by choice. It’s not that he has an ugly face. Rather, he
covers it with a demon mask. However, the mask doesn’t really hide his face as much as it reveals his true character. Ogun is a dark samurai with demon connections. He’s yet another villain who has the humanity that Wolverine so deperately desires and traded it away.

Wolverine’s ugliest villain has got to be Dirt Nap. Even though I didn’t like Genesis as a villain, I enjoyed the Dark Riders who worked for him. They were supposed to be
Apocalypse’s minions but they made for a great team of misfits. Yet one of the Dark Riders was more memorable than the rest. Dirt Nap was a sentient rat. I don’t think
we ever found out if Dirt Nap was a human who mutated into a rat or a rat who gained sentience. Either way, it was a lot of fun to see an actual gutter rat antagonize Wolverine and his friends.

That doesn’t cover everyone who’s ever fought Wolverine. There’s the android team of Albert and Elsie Dee (good). There’s the cyborg Cylla (bad). And there are the many X-Men foes who have tangled with Wolverine on their own: Mystique, Magneto, Masque, Mojo and a few with names that don’t start with the letter “M.” Yet I hope I’ve shown you that Wolverine has a large and varied cast of villains.

The End.

Views: 1216

Comment by The Baron on December 6, 2010 at 5:28pm
Chris, I'd just like to say that even though I don't have any comments to make - not being a huge Wolverine mark -I do read your columns with interest.
Comment by Chris Fluit on December 6, 2010 at 5:54pm
Thanks, Baron.
Comment by Travis Herrick (Modular Mod) on December 8, 2010 at 10:24am
I think most of my Wolverine reading hasn't had his well known foes, so I don't ahve a lot to say about them. I do like Sabretooth, but I've never been able to take him too seriously since I remember him as a Power Man & Iron Fist villain, and he wasn't nearly as powerful then. Misty Knight took him down, no offense Ms. Knight.
Comment by Captain Comics on December 8, 2010 at 5:52pm
I just finished my Marvel Comics Presents collection, and was surprised by how for much of its run it was essentially a Wolverine vehicle. (In fact, I probably didn't buy it originally because it was a Wolverine vehicle, and I was slow to appreciate the character. But I don't really recall.)

I haven't read those issues yet, and might never get around to them. (Another problem I recall with MCP is that the stories were generally by newcomers, and never affected "main" continuity -- so they weren't very good, and weren't at all important. I remember complaining back in the day that MCP amounted to us subsidizing Marvel's training program, so I'm not all that eager to read these. They will probably always remain at the bottom of my to-read stack, which seems to have a healing factor of its own.) Did you read those? Did anything good -- villains or otherwise -- come out of them? Aside from the Barry Windsor-Smith "Weapon X" story, of course, which I did buy off the stands when it first came out.
Comment by Cavaliere (moderator emeritus) on December 8, 2010 at 9:23pm
Aaron Lopresti, who has done terrific artwork for both Marvel and DC, had his first story in MCP. It was a Spider-Man story. That's just off the top of my head.

I liked that MCP would have short stories with characters like Shamrock or Spellbinder who might not have a solo story otherwise.
Comment by Chris Fluit on December 8, 2010 at 9:28pm
I didn't follow MCP at the time as it came out a little bit before I was actively collecting comics again. However, a couple of years back, Marvel produced several trades collecting the Wolverine stories. They petered out at issue 71 (though Sam Kieth's Blood Hungry and, of course, Weapon X, had already been released separately).

Like most anthologies, MCP was a mixture of good and bad. The first story from issues 1-10 was one of the best Wolverine stories I've ever read. It's by Claremont and Buscema and it serves as a prequel to their opening run on the regular Wolverine series. It sets up Madripoor as a base for Wolverine. And it establishes the "Patch" persona, which we discover was never meant to last. It's well worth reading again. I'd put it just behind the Claremont/Miller mini-series, Weapon X and Enemy of the State.

After that, it's up and down. There were some interesting team-ups. I remember enjoying the Hulk and Spider-Man stories, but not the Ghost Rider one. Alpha Flight's Wild Child also shows up as an opponent. But I don't recall any stand-out villains.

Other than the first volume (which collects 1-10), I don't think that I would recommend them for you. Some of the stories are drawn by guys like Rob Liefeld and Erik Larsen, who I know you don't like.


You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!

Join Captain Comics


No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.









© 2020   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service