Over on  Newsarama, Matt Fraction said, "Sometimes I think Defenders was doomed the minute the word Defenders was put on the cover."  I'm curious what other people think.  Is the Defenders a title doomed to fail or is it just that Matt Fraction's Defenders were doomed to fail?

Views: 2711

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Luis Olavo de Moura Dantas said:

Sal Buscema will always be _the_ Defenders artist to me.

I have to agree with you, there. I really can't picture the book under anyone else's hands.

I mostly enjoyed Kraft's run on the title, with the exception of how he handled the "dwarf with a gun" subplot. 

Gerber is without a doubt my favourite.


If forced to pick a second favourite, I'd go with Englehart, if only for the Avengers-Defenders war.

Border Mutt said:

Just out of curiosity, if everyone were to pick their favourite Defender's writer, how many would go with Gerber?

Personally, I would go with JM Demattis, but considering the 12 year old rule comes into play, I'm probably a little biased.  However, my second favourite run was by Busiek on a later series. 

What are everyone else's favourite two runs?

Randy Jackson said:

I mostly enjoyed Kraft's run on the title, with the exception of how he handled the "dwarf with a gun" subplot.

George Poague said:

If only all subplots could be resolved by having a truck run over someone! ;)

Actually, I can't blame the guy. The whole "dwarf with a gun" nonsense was just that -- nonsense, with no point, no purpose, no aim save a bit of whimsy on Steve Gerber's part because Sal Buscema asked for something different to draw. And the dwarf was Gerber's pet character. So if Dave Kraft was uninterested, sure, get rid of him. I don't fault him for that one bit.

What issues comprise the "dwarf with a gun" subplot?  

(And technically, doesn't that deserve a SPOILER ALERT?)

Issue #46 is the last (original) Elf with a Gun appearance.

Yeah, the elf with the gun did come back in the 120s and he even got a change of clothes and showed up in DC's Countdown to Mystery #8.

Anyone else remember elf sightings after the treadmarks?

Elf with a Gun on Wikipedia

Moderator John Dunbar here.

I have deleted 23 posts from this thread.  This was done because the posts violated our Number One Rule - "No Personal Attacks", or quoted posts that violated the rule.  Posts from 6 different members were deleted.

As a reminder for everyone, the rule of "No Personal Attacks" covers comments about fellow posters, comics professionals, entertainers, everyone.  If one poster breaks this rule, this does not give another poster immunity from breaking the rule in response. 

Flame wars will not be tolerated.

Anyone with further questions may send me an email.

On behalf of the moderating team,

John Dunbar

Just to be clear, when John says "On behalf of the moderating team," he's being accurate and not just saying that and acting without our knowledge.

The Moderators have discussed this growing problem probably at too much length. We agree that we've let these feuds and attacks go on too long, because we figured people would get it out of their system and move on. But they keep happening.

We can't edit messages to snip out the offending sections. So if an attack is even a small part of a message, the entire message will be deleted, even if later ones refer to something else in that post. Ideally, that will make it clear where someone is stepping over the line if they don't see the line themselves. Hopefully, that will end the trend.

As with John, you can email me, or any of the moderators, with any questions.

-- MSA

Reply to Discussion



Latest Activity

The Baron replied to Jeff of Earth-J's discussion Harvey Kurtzman
"I don't think I've ever read anything by Kurtzman."
14 minutes ago
Jeff of Earth-J posted a discussion

Harvey Kurtzman

I have not said anything deliberately provocative in a while (and the last time I tried it passed…See More
29 minutes ago
Jeff of Earth-J replied to Wandering Sensei: Moderator Man's discussion What Comic Books Have You Read Today?
"ETERNAL WARRIOR: An omnibus edition of the original Valiant series from the '90s has been…"
1 hour ago
JD DeLuzio replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
"'Nuff said!"
1 hour ago
JD DeLuzio replied to The Baron's discussion Movies I Have Seen Lately
"Hmmm.... Maybe I should have posted my "what are you watching?" post here. Most of the…"
1 hour ago
JD DeLuzio replied to Cavaliere (moderator emeritus)'s discussion What are you watching right now?
"We're three-quarters through Licorice Pizza and will finish it this evening. It's…"
1 hour ago
Jeff of Earth-J replied to Jeff of Earth-J's discussion A Smithsonian Book of Comic-Book Comics
"CAPTAIN MARVEL and C.C. BECK Here, the Smithsonian book deviates from the Feiffer one once again.…"
2 hours ago
Jeff of Earth-J replied to The Baron's discussion Movies I Have Seen Lately
"ANNIE: Another one we chose while flipping through the guide. When I was in high school we played a…"
3 hours ago
Jeff of Earth-J replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
"Father and son robot fighters:"
3 hours ago
Peter Wrexham replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
"Next, Dennis's cousin (their Mums are sisters) Minnie the Minx with her parents.  On the…"
3 hours ago
Richard Willis replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
7 hours ago
The Baron posted a discussion

The World War Two Su[er-Hero I Would Tell If I Could Use Any Characters I wanted

If I could "recruit" whatever characters from whichever comics company I wished and tell any kind…See More
11 hours ago

© 2022   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service