Over in the "TV Shows I Am Binging" thread, I noted that I got hooked on This Is Us, which led to a quick discussion over the show's merits and a pledge to talk about the latest episode. We threw out the idea of having that conversation in the "What Are You Watching Right Now?" thread, but I decided to start one dedicated to the show. Although I titled it "Season 4," I'm not going to limit my observations to that season alone,

So far, it's just been me and Jeff, but I welcome anyone else to join in -- especially Tracy! We've seen too little of you here in the Comics Cave!

Views: 579

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Jeff of Earth-J said:

FEB 23: This episode should have been titled "Planes, Trains and Automobiles." Kudos to casting and make-up for the future versions of Deja, Tess and Annie. Nailed it! 

Oh, man, the casting people deserve all the Emmy awards! I looked at Future Deja and wondered if they somehow got their hands on Doctor Doom's time machine! 

By the way, this episode was directed by Jon Huertas, who plays Miguel. TVLine tells us that he's wanted to try his hand at directing, but chose not to do an episode in which Miguel figured in the story, so he wouldn't have to direct and act. So he got an episode with eight babies and a pregnant actress, which is SO much easier! ("This Is Us Director Jon Huertas Talks Flash-Forward Challenges, Playing Chicken With Mandy Moore's Due Date")

Speaking of Mandy Moore, she and husband Taylor Goldsmith welcomed home baby son August Taylor Goldsmith on Feb. 20.

"I looked at Future Deja and wondered if they somehow got their hands on Doctor Doom's time machine!"

Yes, especially Deja. When Future-Deja first appeared onscreen I thought it might be Lyric Ross, but there are some things one simply cannot accomplish with makeup. In the past, the two versions of William were convincingly similar-looking. Not all of the show's multiple actor roles are as convincing, though. I'm thinking primarily of the actors who play Randall. They don't look much alike at all, but I'm willing to suspend my sense of disbelief because the main thing is that they can act. When the actors look so much alike, that's just icing.

"So he got an episode with eight babies and a pregnant actress..."

Yeah, maybe a better title would have been "Babies and Automobiles." 

I liked this week's episode ("One Small Step..." featuring Nick) better than the last two or three leading up to it. the previous episodes had become a bit too formulaic, but I was uncertain how the various plot threads would resolve this week. for example, I still don't know whether or not Nicky made his rendezvous with his girlfriend in time t make it to Woodstock. The implication is that he did not, but it could go either way. Perhaps a future episode will reveal he showed up at the last minute.

Last week's episode featured Phylicia Rashad. I recently saw her in Creed II (along with Milo Ventimiglia, although they had no scenes together). Her performance brings a certain gravitas to both roles, but I must say Mary Anne Creed is much more sympathetic than Carol Clarke (although they did try to soften her up toward the end). It should be "interesting" with her continuing to live in Randall and Beth's household.

I already have an opinion about next week's episode, but I guess I'll wait to say something until I actually see it. 

I feel I have a lot in common with Uncle Nick (the "uncle" part). 

We didn't discuss the substance of the previous two episodes much.* But to recap quickly:

  • When Randall and Beth were bringing baby Annie home and Randall kept pressing Beth to try again, this time for a boy, I so wanted to reach into my TV screen and shake him and say, "NOT TODAY, DUDE! NOT TODAY! Shut up, already!" I know he meant well, and it was explained that it comes from him spending his entire life longing for family, but still.
  • When Kate and Toby were bringing their baby home and birth mother Ellie gets upset and declares she doesn't want to be in her life, and Kate started to argue with her, I so wanted to reach into my TV screen and shake her and say, "NOT TODAY, KATE! NOT TODAY! Shut up, already!" I know she meant well, and it was explained that it comes from her spending her entire life watching Randall longing for family, but still
  • Fortunately, Toby talked Kate off the ledge, rightfully pointing out that today's conversation doesn't have to be the final one.
  • How about Kevin's dream where he had a talk with Jack? Interestingly enough, it was Jack from his kid years (signified by his mustache) and not Jack from his teenage years. (That Jack has a Van Dyke beard.)
  • Y'know, I never liked the casting of Phylicia Rashad as Beth's mother. She does the imperious mom bit very well ... a little too well, and in too many other places (the Creed series, Empire, A Raisin in the Sun, and, most famously, The Cosby Show). I would rather have had Vanessa Bell Calloway, who is a wonderful, unheralded actress, and a dancer like Susan Kelechi Watson, and has a closer resemblance to her too. But I'm not on the This Is Us casting team, which usually hits it out of the park.
  • I could feel Toby's frustration with applying for job after job online and getting nowhere, and walking into Kevin's house -- Golden Boy Kevin, who walked away from a movie in production and still gets gifts from his Hollywood friends. I know I thought the fallout from that wouldn't be impossible to navigate, but I didn't think there would be no fallout at all.

* I was drafting a response, but I lost it. I haven't learned yet that when I have a long response in the offing, I shouldn't write it in this space; I should write it elsewhere and paste it in.

Reply to Discussion



No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.









© 2021   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service