Reviewed: 'Yiddishkeit,' 'Bruce Timm: Naughty and Nice'

Andrew A. Smith

Scripps Howard News Service


We're all Yiddishkeit now




Ever wonder why you know so many Yiddish words, fellow goyim? I know I have – I’ve used words like putz, schmuck, klutz and schnozz most of my life, without any idea where I picked them up. Was it from MAD magazine? The Marx Brothers? Fiddler on the Roof? Stan Lee (Stanley Lieber) and Jack Kirby (Jacob Kurtzberg) at Marvel Comics? Blazing Saddles and other Mel Brooks movies?


It could have been any or all, because American entertainment is thoroughly suffused with the sensibilities of Yiddish-speaking Jews, a people who fled pogroms in places like Poland and Russia to the New World. These gentle folk from the rural villages of Eastern Europe had a unique viewpoint and wry sense of humor that was embraced in cultural meccas like Hollywood and New York City. From there, they taught boys from Tacoma to Tampa to want to be a mensch, and girls to want to be zaftig.


Which is why I have always wanted a book like Yiddishkeit: Jewish Vernacular & the New Land (Abrams ComicArts, $32.95). Edited by Paul Buhle and the late Harvey Pekar, Yiddishkeit traces the history and influence of Yiddish from medieval Europe to the tenements of New York’s Lower East Side through a collection of comics stories.


It’s more than just a history, though, because Yiddishkeit is a sprawling, untranslatable concept that embodies a language, a culture, a set of values, a way of thinking, a sensibility. Sure, we learn a lot of historical facts in Yiddishkeit,but if you don’t feel what the words and pictures are conveying, you’re missing the best part.


And there’s probably nobody better for this task than Harvey Pekar, famed for his American Splendor comic books and movie, and the Our Cancer Year graphic novel. Pekar’s relentless perfectionism and irritable kvetching are as much a reflection of Yiddishkeit as the funny stuff, and his stamp is all over the book, especially in the pieces he wrote. Pekar died in 2010, and Yiddishkeit is probably his last sustained professional effort.


Comics fans will recognize other names as well, including Danny Fingeroth (a long-time Spider-Man editor), Peter Kuper (The Jungle, among others) and Spain Rodriguez (Trashman, Che: A Graphic Biography). Plus there’s co-editor Buhle, who’s written 42 books, several about the intersection of Jews and comic books.


From these diverse – and all-star – hands arises Yiddishkeit, felt more with the heart than understood with the head. Which is itself reflective of the Jewish experience, and its influence on America.


So don’t be a schmoe! Get off your tukhus and buy Yiddishkeit already!




"Good girl art” is a comic-book term that really means “good and sexy.” Which gives you an idea what’s in Naughty and Nice: The Good Girl Art of Bruce Timm (Flesk, $50).


But there’s a twist: Timm is the animation genius who gave us Batman: The Animated Series, and a veteran of various animation studios, so these sexy girls – most in states of undress – have a definite cartoonish vibe. So, although I wouldn’t show this book to the kiddies, it’s more arty (cartoony?) than dirty. Somehow, despite the nudity, these pin-ups are almost wholesome, more coquettish than slutty.


Another delightful aspect of the book is that DC Entertainment has allowed Timm to include a number of (fully dressed) heroines from their comic books, some of which Timm has personally re-invented for the small screen. So you’ll see Batgirl, Poison Ivy, Catwoman and other Bat-characters, plus a great many DC supergirls we’ve never seen him draw before.

A further interesting angle is that Timm is clearly not a fan of the exaggerated busts so typical of comic books. His girls are all petite. Even when dealing with notoriously top-heavy characters like Power Girl and Big Barda, he keeps the hip-waist-bust ratio plausibly proportioned.


I confess that after a while a lot of these pin-ups – all of the same body type, all of them sloe-eyed and girlish – tend to blur together. But the book amply demonstrates something I’ve always admired about Timm’s art: His ability to effortlessly render his women with a perfect center of gravity, their weight balanced as easily on the page as it would be in life. When you consider he is doing this with just a few curved strokes – where other artists fail at the same task with labored “photorealism” and heavy textures – it leaves this wannabe artist slack-jawed in amazement.


In short, Naughty and Niceis pretty much the only title this book could have.


Contact Andrew A. Smith of the Memphis Commercial Appeal at



1. Yiddishkeit is an anthology of comics stories illustrating the history and influence of Eastern European Jews on American culture. Courtesy Abrams ComicArts

2. Naughty and Nice is a collection of pin-ups from master animator Bruce Timm. Courtesy Flesk Publications

Views: 2029

Comment by Emerkeith Davyjack on February 9, 2012 at 8:17pm


  When did the phrse " Good Girl Art " get invented , anyway ?????????

  Are there any fully nude - or , more nude than the DC characters are , anyway ? - drawings in Timm's opus ???

Comment by Emerkeith Davyjack on February 9, 2012 at 8:24pm

...David T. Alexander , say Wikipedia !!!!!!!!!!! That's nice to know . :-) I knew/thought it was a comics/perhaps similar items dealers' invention , to try and see (cynical) nondescript funnybooks with girlie art...and , some prime examples of that , too , to be not as cynical !!!!!!!!!!!

  I remember a Don Rosa drawing , illustrating " What They Should Mean By ' GOOD GIRL ART ': "_____showing a Little Miss Muffett and her lamb !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Comment by Captain Comics on February 9, 2012 at 8:47pm

As I said in the article, the DC characters are all fully clothed. I doubt DC would let him use them otherwise!

Dunno the origin of "good girl art." It's been around forever, probably as early as the '40s. If it precedes comics, it could go back farther than that. Anybody know?

Comment by Emerkeith Davyjack on February 9, 2012 at 8:57pm

...I just mean the term .

  Is the book all DC properties , then ?????????

Comment by Captain Comics on February 9, 2012 at 9:00pm

No, just one chapter has DC characters. The rest is all Timm.

As to "good girl art," I meant the term also. It was used in reference to work in the '40s and '50s, so it's been around a while.


You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!

Join Captain Comics


No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.









© 2020   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service