That darn Barry Alllen! He comes back and leaves a mess all over the place!


DC relaunches all titles post-Flashpoint

Views: 1203

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Here's my ideal list. (And yes, I give in to a few of my favorite obscure characters...)
  1. Alpha Centurion
  2. Aquaman
  3. Batman
  4. Batman -- Brave & the Bold (Team-up book)
  5. Batman -- Detective Comics
  6. Batman -- Robin
  7. Batman -- Batgirl/Batwoman
  8. Batman -- Gotham's Underworld
  9. Black Lightning & The Outsiders
  10. Blue Beetle & Booster Gold -- Super Friends
  11. Butcher (The Indian tracker dude)
  12. Captain Atom
  13. Captain Marvel
  14. Charlton team (Featuring Captain Atom, Blue Beetle, Son of Vulcan, Question, Judomaster, Nightshade, etc.)
  15. Cyborg
  16. Deadman
  17. Firestorm
  18. Flash
  19. Flash -- Rogue's Gallery
  20. Freedom Fighters
  21. El Diablo
  22. Gen 13 
  23. Green Arrow
  24. Green Lantern
  25. Green Lantern -- Lantern Corps
  26. Grifter
  27. Hawk & Dove (Birds of Prey?)
  28. Hawkman
  29. Justice League
  30. Justice League -- Justice League International
  31. Justice Society
  32. Legion of Superheroes
  33. Manhunters (All versions as a team?)
  34. Miss Martian
  35. Mister Terrific
  36. New Gods -- Darkseid
  37. New Gods -- Mister Miracle and Big Barda
  38. Plastic Man
  39. Powergirl
  40. Secret Six
  41. Showcase (Monthly double-sized issue at $2.99 price, features one full-length lead character plus one multi-part 8 page backup, plus one done-in-one 8-page backup, plus 5 pages of Who's Who entries.)
  42. Son of Vulcan
  43. Stargirl -- Stars and Stripes
  44. Superman
  45. Superman -- Action Comics
  46. Superman -- Lex Luthor's Crime Bible
  47. Superman -- Supergirl
  48. Teen Titans
  49. Teen Titans -- Beast Boy
  50. Wildcats 
  51. Wonder Woman
  52. Zatanna

Some key people I left out: Nightwing, Batgirl or Batwoman, Dr. Fate, Martian Manhunter (in favor of Miss Martian), the Authority, the Atom, Metamorpho, Swamp Thing and probably a few others.

Adventure Comics (with the Legion characters) will probably start over.
DC has announced its Green Lantern titles post-relaunch. The press release can be found here.

Our sister site,, has compiled what information there is about the reboot, and will keep adding to it. Their efforts can be found here:


15 titles announced in DC relaunch


DC explains digital plans; retailers react

Have any of you seen this covered in the media, I mean other than USA Today?  I ask because here in Nova Scotia there was an AP wire story about this in the Halifax Chronicle-Herald yesterday, complete with picture of Geoff Johns.  It's pretty rare to have any stories about comics featured in this paper at all, yet here this was, mentioning the relaunch with all the new #1's, and the day and date digital info.  Then it listed 10 new books and their creative teams***, but despite the picture of Johns the article did not mention Justice League #1 being the kickoff, nor does the article mention Jim Lee at all.


*** For the record, they are Green Arrow, JLI, Mr. Terrific, Fury of Firestorm, Captain Atom, Aquaman, Wonder Woman, Savage Hawkman, Flash, and DC Comics Presents

The Associated Press has really stepped up its comics coverage in the last year. I suspect they hired an entertainment reporter that is comics savvy rathere than this a reflection of a concerted effort by the AP to boost coverage. Since this reporter (alwys the same guy) is probably based in NYC, its probably very easy to land exclusive interviews. _
The article I mention above didn't list a reporter, just had "AP" after the headline, and had Philadelphia as the locale it was reported from.  It wasn't an interview;  just seemed to be a reworded press release.  It reminded me of the posts Cap puts up in the "Comics News" group on this site.
It occurs to me suddenly why J.H. Williams' Batwoman #1 kept getting postponed (the last schedule was April)  -- they're finally going to ship it with the other #1s. Duh. Sometimes I'm slow. So now we know one more book than the 15 they've told us about.

Capt. Comics said: "Even after Green Lantern and Flash had been other guys for years, the general public still thought they were Hal Jordan and Barry Allen (even if they couldn't remember their names).That's how important the original DCU was -- even after all these years, it's still the baseline."


Yep, and it's Hal Jordan in next month's GL movie. And it will be Barry Allen in the planned Flash flick. A triumph for the baby boomers -- our versions of these guys are still the ones that count.

I hate to put it in those terms, George, especially since Boomer-bashing is so popular today. I'd just say that Jordan and Allen were the most famous and successful characters to carry the handles Green Lantern and Flash, and replacing them is a low-percentage move.


Moreover -- and I think we all saw this during the times when Jordan and Allen were dead -- removing those characters in order to replace them leaves a huge hole in history and continuity. You need them for the story to be whole, and if they're there, they're going to be the leads -- they can't take a secondary role, or they are not the same characters. Also, it would be out of character for the younger characters to aggressively replace them. You may be the most successful guy among your peers, but if your Dad's around, you're going to defer.


So I think it's the inevitable triumph of story structure. You can't remove Hal Jordan and Barry Allen willy-nilly without destroying the franchises.

You can't remove Hal Jordan and Barry Allen willy-nilly without destroying the franchises.

Oh, they got along without Barry for 25 years before they revived him. And I don't think they revived him because the franchise had been destroyed, they did it because, um, actually, I don't really know why they thought they had to do it. Frankly, I think they revived him pretty willy nilly.

Barry's lineage was so strong that his absence was a big point. No way did a Flash take the job without knowing it was dangerous. He was a legend they had to live up to. Even Jay was wearing a WWBD bracelet.

And I actually think they had a reasonably good epic storyline going when Hal went rogue and became a villain. He could've become DC's Galactus with a way, way better backstory. The greatest GL becomes the universe's most feared villain, privy to many of the biggest secrets of his foes! But they couldn't handle it. Brawk-brawk-brawk.

Granted, part of the problem was the guy they replaced him with was such a jamoke and so transparently aimed at Gen Xers that he was hard to swallow. Wally had that same problem, but at least he didn't appear out of nowhere.

I think Barry and Hal's problems added to the DCU. But Dead Barry and Galactic Hal aren't much for selling action figures, so they finally gave in to their accountants' memos and brought them back.

I don't think it has anything to do with Boomers directly. I think it has to do with when things were new and first being discovered. That's what injects the characters with awe and wonder that remains. Their origins are pretty straighforward, too. Using Wally or Kyle in origin stories would be tough on their own without changes. Wally was standing around a bunch of chemicals in a lightning storm because, um...

Any movie executive courting the Baby Boomer market with his summer action movie is not going to last in his job too long these days. They all go to the matinee shows when prices are cheap.

-- MSA

There are several reasons why Barry and Hal were revived (note that I'm not saying they had to be revived). When they were taken out of the equation and DC virtually pinky-swore that Wally and Kyle were the heroes now, they never really went away. The Return of Barry Allen, Emerald Knights, Final Night, JLA: Year One, Legends of the DC Universe, The Brave & The Bold, The Spectre starring Hal, even JLA/Avengers featured them and still made them look better than their replacements. Mark Waid and Alex Ross ignored Kyle altogether in Kingdom Come and get starring roles to the two in Justice. Because that's who they want to write and draw about, like Geoff Johns and Jim Lee.

Even though it was Kyle who appeared in Superman: The Animated Series with Hal's origin, no less, and it was Wally (as we eventually found out) and John Stewart featured in Justice League and JL Unlimited, it was always Barry and Hal that most creators were interested in working with. With movies of the pair now a reality, their origins are purest and free from prior incarnations as they had no real links with their Golden Age counterparts.

DC was dying to bring back Hal. In Kevin Smith's Green Arrow (which proves my point, BTW) when Hal and Ollie meet in Hero Heaven and Hal is the Spectre:

"So when are you coming back, Hal?"

"I am back, Ollie."

"No when are you coming back for real?

"Working on it."

And DC was. It was so successful and the older fans cheered! "YAAAAAAY!!!" that they did it again with the Flash because the writer wanted Barry and by this point, why not? 

Reply to Discussion



No flame wars. No trolls. But a lot of really smart people.The Captain Comics Round Table tries to be the friendliest and most accurate comics website on the Internet.









© 2021   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service