We start with The Wizard of Oz, by L. Frank Baum, first published on May 7, 1900.
- The illustrations are by W.W. Denslow, who depicts Dorothy as a young girl (maybe around eight) with dark hair
- Baum's "Kansas" is very bleak. From what I've read, it's more like the Dakota that Baum knew than the actual Kansas.
- Re-reading this book, you realize just how much the 1939 mpvie simply made up. Emlira Gulch, Professor Marvel, Zeke, Hunk and Hickory are not present in the book, In the book, Dorothy doesn't run away, she misses getting into the storm cellar because she was chasing Toto, who was hiding under the bed.
- The witch who sends Dorothy to the Emerald City is not Glinda, but instead is the Good Witch of the North, who is not named here. There is no appearance by the Wicked Witch of the West in this part of the story.
- We get the first mention of Oz being surrounded by an impassable desert.
- The magic footwear are Silver Shoes and not Ruby Slippers. Dorothy puts them on because her old shoes were worn out, and not at the Witch's suggestion.
- We learn that the land is divided between the Munchkins in the east, the Winkies in the west, the Quadlings in the south, and the people of the north, who aren't named here. Initially, only the area around the Emerald City is called "the Land of Oz", after the Wizard. the Munchkins' national color is blue.
- No explanation is given as to how the Scarecrow comes to be alive. He reveaals that he was created only the day before yesterday.
- The Tin Woodman's origin is wild. He was a mormal man who wanted to marry a girl he was into. The girl's guardian objected, and paid off a witch to enchant his axe so that every time he used it, it would cut off a body part, which he would have replced with a tin prosthesis, Eventually his entire body was replaced, and he lost interest in the girl because he no longer had a heart. Two questions here: "How did he survive all this?" and "Why did he keep using the axe after the second or maybe third time that it happened?"
- Lots of animals get killed in this book. The Tin Woodman kills a beetle, the Lion offers to kill a deer for Dorothy to eat, and they kill some monsters called "Kalidahs" It is established that all animals are intelligent - well, I'm not sure about insects. Anyway, the whole issue of whether killing an intelligent animal onstitutes murder, or what - or is it "who" - carnivores eat is kind of skirted around. Toto cannot speak in Oz, I giess because he's not a local pup.
- In the book, the poppy field has nothing to do with the Wicked Witch, and Glinda doesn't save them. The Scarecrow and the Tin Woodman carry Dorothy and Toto out of the field. The Woodman coincidentally kills a wildcat that was chasing the Queen of the Field Mice. In gratitude, she has a few thousand of her subjects help the boys haul the Lion to safety.
- Everyone in the Emerald City must wear green glasses, ostensibly to protect them from glare, but actually to cover up the fact that most of the city is, in reality, white. I'm reasonably certain that this is never mentioned again.
- Dorothy and her associates visit the Wizard individually, and not as a group. He appears to Dorothy as a Big Giant Head, to the Scarerow as a beautiful winged woman, to the Tin Woodman as a Horrific Beast and to thr Lion as a Fireball.
- Chickens and storks also exist in Oz
- The Tin Woodman slaughters a pack of wolves sent by the Witch with his axe. The Scarecrow slaughters a murder of crows by twisting their necks with his bare hands. Bet crows are scared of him, now! the Woodman kills a swarn of bees, and the Lion frightens off some spearmen. Can't kill off humans, I guess.
- The illustration of the Wicked Witch of the West looks nothing like Margaret Hamilton's depiction. She looks more like if the Sea Hag had a cousin who liked to cosplay as obscure anime characters.
- The Witch using a Magi Cap to ccontrol the Winged Monkeys, because the Monkey King's grandfather p*ssed off a princess. The monkeys capture Dorothy, Toto and the Lion after battering the Scarecrow and te Woodman.
- The Winkies' color is yellow.
- The Witch is afraid of the dark.
- Dorothy throws a bucket of water at the Witch after the Witch stole one of her shoes. The Winkies retrieve and repair the Scarecrow and the Woodman. Doorthy takes the Golden Cap. There's nothing about needing the Witch's broomstick.
- The Wizard claims that he commissioned the building of the Emerald City. His illustration depicts him as a dumpy little bald guy.
- The Wizard gives the Scarerow a "brain" made of bran, pins and needles, the Woodman a silk heart stuffed with sawdust, and the Lion a drink of Liquid Courage. (I've had a taste or two of that over they years, m'self.)
- After the Wizad's departure, our heroes decide to go see Glinda, instead of Glinda coming to them, as in the movie.
- They meet the Fighting Trees on this trip, as well as a city full of people made of fine china, and the Hammer-Heads, a race of cheerfully hostile headbutters who are armless but not 'armless.
- The Lion becomes King of the Forest a giant spider that's been terrorizing the animals. He does this by courageously waiting until it's asleep and tearing its head off before it could defend itself. (Hey, it's all very well to be brave, but there's no need to be stupid about it.)
- The Quadling national color is red.
- glinda reveals that she will use the Monkeyd to return the Scsrecrow to rule the Emerald City, the Woodman to rule the Winkies and the Lion to rule the Animals, after which she will set them free. I can see why people do conspiracy theories about this story, since it ends with the Witches dead, the Wizard gone, and people that Glinda can easily control in charge of the Emerald City and Winkieland. I bet that if Dorothy had wanted to stay and become the Kanzlerin of Munchkinland, Glinda would've lived with that. I also bet that the Witch of the North keeps a very low profile.
- Glinda explains how Dorothy can use the Silver Shoes to get home. It does not involve saying "There's no place like home." The shoes are lost during Dorothy's return home.
- Dorothy's homecoming is anticlimactic. Uncle Henry has a new farmhouse. Guess he had good insurance.
- Oz is a real place and not just a dream in the book.
Overall: Some weird, wild stuff in here. If all you know is the movie, you should definitely give this book a read, sometime.
Replies
Next is The Road to Oz, by L.Frank Baum, first published July 10, 1909
Overall: It's an interesting story. I feel like Baum is trying t tie all of his books together.
Next is The Emerald City of Oz, L. Frank Baum, first published July 20, 1910.
Overall: An OK story - lots of dark stuff in this, though.
Next is The Patchwork Girl of Oz, by L. Frank Baum, first published July 1, 1913.
Overall: An OK story. Not that big of a fan of the Patchwork Girl, myself.
Next up is Tik-Tok of Oz, by L. Frank Baum, first published June 19, 1914.
Overall: This was weird, because I know I've read it before, but I didn't remember it at all. A lot of it feels like retreads of elements of previous stories, and Tik-Tok isn't even that much of a presence in it.
Next is The Scarecrow of Oz, by L. Frank Baum, first published July 16, 1915.
Overall: This is another book that I had very little memory of. It's OK, but I'm getting the impression that Baum really didn't want to write Oz stories anymore, so he just shoehorned some Oz stuff onto stories about other places.
Next up is Rinkitink in Oz, by L. Frank Baum, first published June 20, 1916.
Overall: It was OK, maybe not as good as I remember it being when I was little. It's barely an Oz book, and when the Ozites do show up, it's to be a deus ex machina to solve all the heroes' problems. It's almost as if Baum couldn't think of a way to have Inga solve his problems on his own.
Next up is The Lost Princess of Oz, by L. frsnk Baum, first published June 5,1917.
Overall: This one was pretty good, the best one in a while, and it was actually set in Oz, for once.
Next is the Tin Woodman of Oz, by L. Frank Baum, first published May 13, 1918.
Overall: Not a bad story, but, good grief, there's lots of weird stuff in here! I don't know that I'd want a little kid reading it.
Next is The Magic of Oz, by L. Frank Baum, first published on June 7, 1919.
Overall: This is an OK book. It almost feels as though it would have made for a good "finale" to the series, with a last battle with Ruggedo and most of the characters gathered at the end for a party like it was an Asterix book. I wonder to what extent Baum knew or suspected that he would be jobbing to the Reaper soon...