Best Writer: 2003: Mark Waid 2004: Brad Meltzer 2005: Geoff Johns 2006: Ed Brubaker 2007: Ed Brubaker 2008: Geoff Johns 2009: Ed Brubaker/Geoff Johns (tie)
Best Artist: 2003: George Perez 2004: John Cassaday 2005: Darwyn Cooke 2006: John Cassaday 2007: Terry and Rachel Dodson 2008: George Perez 2009: JH Williams III
Best Self-Contained Story (single issue or one-shot): 2003: Fantastic Four 500 2004: --- 2005: Fantastic Four 524 (Mark Waid and Mike Wieringo's final issue) 2006: Astro City: Samaritan Special 2007: Green Lantern: Sinestro Corps Special 2008: All-Star Superman 10 (the Kandor issue) 2009: Jonah Hex 50
Best Story Arc: 2005: "I Can't Believe It's Not the Justice League," JLA Classified 2006: "Up, Up and Away," Action Comics and Superman 2007: "The Sinestro Corps War," Green Lantern and Green Lantern Corps 2008: "Blue and Gold," Booster Gold 2009: “Blackest Night,” Green Lantern and others
2010: “The Return of Bruce Wayne,” Batman titles
2011: “James Gordon Jr.,” Detective Comics
2012: “Night of the Owls,” Batman titles
2013: “Zero Year,” Batman
2014: “Spider-Verse,” Amazing Spider-man and others
Best Limited Series: 2003: Formerly Known as the Justice League 2004: JLA/Avengers 2005: Green Lantern: Rebirth 2006: Infinite Crisis 2007: 52 2008: Final Crisis: Legion of Three Worlds 2009: Blackest Night
Replies
Best Writer:
2003: Mark Waid
2004: Brad Meltzer
2005: Geoff Johns
2006: Ed Brubaker
2007: Ed Brubaker
2008: Geoff Johns
2009: Ed Brubaker/Geoff Johns (tie)
2010: Geoff Johns
2011: Scott Snyder
2012: Brian K. Vaughan
2013: Brian K. Vaughan
2014: Kurt Busiek
Best Artist:
2003: George Perez
2004: John Cassaday
2005: Darwyn Cooke
2006: John Cassaday
2007: Terry and Rachel Dodson
2008: George Perez
2009: JH Williams III
2010: JH Williams III
2011: Marcos Martin
2012: Fiona Staples
2013: Francisco Francavilla
2014: Fiona Staples
Most Underrated Writer:
2005: Dan Slott
2006: Dan Slott
2007: Greg Pak/John Rogers (tie)
2008: Peter Tomasi
2009: Jay Faerber
2010: Chris Roberson
2011: Chris Roberson
2012: Gail Simone
2013: Charles Soule
2014: Nathan Edmondson
Most Underrated Artist:
2005: Frank Cho
2006: Darwyn Cooke
2007: Colleen Coover/Duncan Rouleau (tie)
2008: Nicola Scott
2009: Jill Thompson
2010: Jill Thompson
2011: Francisco Francavilla
2012: Fiona Staples
2013: Paul Pelletier
2014: Nick Dragotta
Best Self-Contained Story (single issue or one-shot):
2003: Fantastic Four 500
2004: ---
2005: Fantastic Four 524 (Mark Waid and Mike Wieringo's final issue)
2006: Astro City: Samaritan Special
2007: Green Lantern: Sinestro Corps Special
2008: All-Star Superman 10 (the Kandor issue)
2009: Jonah Hex 50
2010: Fables 100
2011: Detective Comics 875
2012: Wolverine & the X-Men 17 (the Doop issue)
2013: Hawkeye 11 (Pizza is my business)
2014: Edge of Spider-Verse 2 (Gwen Stacy)
Best Story Arc:
2005: "I Can't Believe It's Not the Justice League," JLA Classified
2006: "Up, Up and Away," Action Comics and Superman
2007: "The Sinestro Corps War," Green Lantern and Green Lantern Corps
2008: "Blue and Gold," Booster Gold
2009: “Blackest Night,” Green Lantern and others
2010: “The Return of Bruce Wayne,” Batman titles
2011: “James Gordon Jr.,” Detective Comics
2012: “Night of the Owls,” Batman titles
2013: “Zero Year,” Batman
2014: “Spider-Verse,” Amazing Spider-man and others
Best Limited Series:
2003: Formerly Known as the Justice League
2004: JLA/Avengers
2005: Green Lantern: Rebirth
2006: Infinite Crisis
2007: 52
2008: Final Crisis: Legion of Three Worlds
2009: Blackest Night
2010: Cinderella: From Fabletown with Love
2011: The Red Wing
2012: Before Watchmen: Minutemen
2013: Infinity
2014: Multiversity
Best Ongoing Series:
2003: Fantastic Four
2004: Fantastic Four
2005: Fables
2006: Captain America/Green Lantern (tie)
2007: Captain America
2008: Fables
2009: Fables
2010: Life with Archie
2011: Daredevil
2012: Daredevil
2013: Superior Spider-Man
2014: Astro City
Best New Title:
2007: Booster Gold
2008: Incredible Hercules
2009: Secret Warriors
2010: American Vampire
2011: Daredevil
2012: Saga
2013: East of West
2014: Grayson
Most Underrated Title:
2005: She-Hulk
2006: Runaways
2007: Blue Beetle
2008: The Order
2009: Captain Britain and MI:13
2010: Life with Archie
2011: OMAC
2012: The Unwritten
2013: Lazarus
2014: Black Widow