Doctor Who: Once and Future

PAST LIVES:

large.jpg

The Time War. The Doctor has been injured and brought to a Time Lord field hospital. His body glows with energy, but this is no regeneration into a future form - instead, the Doctor’s past faces begin to appear as he flits haphazardly between incarnations...

Staggering to his TARDIS, the Doctor sets out to solve the mystery of his 'degeneration'. Who has done this to him? How? And why? From the Earth to the stars, across an array of familiar times and places, he follows clues to retrace his steps, encountering old friends and enemies along the way. Tumbling through his lives, the Doctor must stop his degeneration before he loses himself completely...

Settling as his Fourth incarnation, the Doctor goes in search of the Monk, with a vague memory that he had something to do with his degeneration.

On Earth, the Monk is meddling, bringing Sarah Jane Smith to the future UNIT HQ to steal a device for an alien race. The Doctor must help Kate Stewart and Osgood foil an invasion before he can confront the Monk about what he knows...

  • The Doctor - Tom Baker
  • The Monk - Rufus Hound
  • Sarah Jane Smith - Sadie Miller
  • Kate Lethbridge-Stewart - Jemma Redgrave
  • Petronella Osgood - Ingrid Oliver

With special appearances by:

  • The First Doctor - Stephen Noonan
  • The Second Doctor - Michael Troughton
  • TheThird Doctor - Tim Treloar
  • The Fifth Doctor - Peter Davison
  • The Sixth Doctor - Colin Baker
  • The Seventh Doctor - Sylvester McCoy

For anyone who has read my previous Doctor Who posts, most of these names should be familiar. Sadie Miller is Elisabeth Sladen's daughter, and Michael Troughton is Patrick Troughton's son; they both do a better-than-passing imitation of their respective parents.Tim Trelor has been featured in a series of "Third Doctor Adventures" and one would be hard-pressed to tell him apart from Jon Pertwee. And Rufus Hound has assayed the role of the Monk many times. I am not as familiar with Stephen Noonan as the First Doctor, but based on his performance here I have no complaints. I had no trouble whatsoever determining which Doctor was speaking as he changed form rapidly during the early stages of the "degeneration."

220px-Sirens_of_Time.jpg

I am reminded of "The Sirens of Time," the very first Doctor Who audio Big Finish ever made and the first one I listened to. When I listened to it the very first time, I had seen only one each Fifth, Sixth and Seventh Doctor story on TV. They each had their own section, then came together in the end. At the time, I wasn't familiar enough with their respective voices to tell which was speaking in the final chapter and consequently didn't appreciate it as much as I did in later listenings. "Once and Future" was the centerpiece of Big Finish's 60th anniversary celebration of Doctor Who in 2023, but "Sirens of Time" is celebrating its own 25th anniversary this year. To commemorate it, a re-edited version has been released which involves all three of the Doctors participating throughout, rather than just coming together at the end.

From Sarah Jane's point of view, her part of the story begins just moments after the Doctor dropped her off in South Croydon (or what she thought was South Croydon) when she is kidnappedby the Meddling Monk. It's something off a call-back to the the (Eighth) Doctor left Charley Pollard behind and she is picked up monents later by the Sixth Doctor, or even when the Ninth Doctor left Rose at the end of "Rose" then reappeared "moments" later (of course that was the Doctor she expected). I usually post my thoughts about these episodes when they are still fresh in my mind, but we listened to three of them over the course of a roadtrip over the weekend. Luckily, these days Big Finish releases TRAILERS to supplement my thoughts.

You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!

Join Captain Comics

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • THE ARTIST AT THE END OF TIME:

    large.jpg

    Suffering the effects of degeneration, the Doctor heads towards the end of the universe in search of answers. Instead, he finds his daughter - Jenny - and an Artist whose works appear to mark the end of every world they touch.

    The Doctor stabilises into his Fifth form to join forces with Jenny and the Curator to solve the mystery of the Final Gallery and the art it has collected.

    • The Doctor - Peter Davison
    • Jenny - Georgia Tennant
    • The Curator - Colin Baker

    With special appearances by:

    • The First Doctor - Stephen Noonan
    • The Second Doctor - Michael Troughton
    • TheThird Doctor - Tim Treloar
    • The Sixth Doctor - Colin Baker
    • The Seventh Doctor - Sylvester McCoy

    This episode has fun with the fact that Georgia Tennant is Peter Davison's daughter IRL. (She refers to him as "Dad" throughout.) Georgia has really come into her own as Jenny, and said as much during her interview on the "extras" section. She didn't really feel at home with the role after only a single appearance on TV, but by now she has had two "seasons" of solo audio adventures and has guested on others as well. Colin Baker took over the role of The Currator from Tom Baker in the Stranded series. At this point in The Currator's existence, he is travelling the universe painting portraits of planets he has visited, but every one of them is destroyed after he has left. (It is revealed that the his very first work was "Gallifrey Falls / No More" from "The Day of the Doctor.") At first he was guilt-striken when he found out because he thought he might somehow have been causing each plaent's destruction, but it is eventually revealed that a group of collectors has been obtaining each painting then destroying the planets in order to increase the value of the paintings. He eventually brought the cycle to an end by painting a portrait of the planet which housed the gallery of his art and the collectors' automated planet destroyer wiped it out of existence. He also lays some pretty broad (yet cryptic hints) hints of what the future will bring to the Fifth Doctor and Jenny.

    TRAILER

    Jenny - The Doctor's Daughter
    It’s time for me to take a break from the Sixth Doctor’s adventures and look at those of his daughter (five times removed). This is one of those seri…
  • A GENIUS FOR WAR:

    large.jpg

    In the midst of the Time War, the Time Lords have received a communication from Falkus, the prison moon of Skaro. Its sole inmate, Davros, wishes to make them an offer.

    He will help them win the Time War... but only if the Doctor comes to his rescue.

    • The Doctor - Sylvester McCoy
    • Davros - Terry Molloy

    With special appearances by:

    • The First Doctor - Stephen Noonan
    • The Second Doctor - Michael Troughton
    • TheThird Doctor - Tim Treloar

    This plot is pretty staightforward (i.e., easy to follow) on the surface. Davros is to be put on trial for treason by the Daleks. He has appealed to the Time Lords for help, but can he be trusted to actually turn against the race he created? The answer is "no." Basically, he has made a similar plea to the Daleks themselves and is playing both ends against the middle. The Time Lords have pulled the "Seventh" Doctor out of time; Davros will deal only with the Doctor. The Time Lords are aware of the Doctor's condition, but have no idea what's causing it.

    Here is the one TRAILER my 100 words are worth.

  • TWO'S COMPANY:

    large.jpg

    Back on Earth, the Doctor finds a clue in the search for the origins of the degeneration weapon. In his Sixth body, he meets Jackie Tyler and Lady Christina de Souza - thrown together by fate, or something more? - in pursuit of a powerful item of jewellery.

    Meanwhile, a Time Lord renegade has duped Harry Sullivan into helping him stop the Doctor's travels before they begin - and all are set on a collision course.

    • The Doctor - Colin Baker
    • Jackie Tyler - Camille Coduri
    • Lady Christina de Souza - Michelle Ryan
    • Harry Sullivan - Christopher Naylor
    • Renegade - Michael Maloney

    With special appearance by:

    • TheThird Doctor - Tim Treloar

    Here's another unlikely conglomeration of Doctor Who characters from across time. You wouldn't think Jackie Tyler and Lady Christina de Souza would have much in common, but they play quite surprisingly well off one another. A woman named "Melody" put them together for a "job"; Jackie assumed it was for a cleaning job, and Lady Christina assumed Jackie wanted to hire her. The macguffin this time is a Time Lord artifact that looks like a necklace, which Rose gave to her mother. One thing I hadn't realized is that none of the "degenerations" has memories beyond his own. What I mean is, although this "Sixth" Doctor has memories of the "Seventh" from the previous epside, he has no memory of Jackie Tyler... although she, of course, knows him (or at least a "future" aspect of "him"). The "Time Lord renegade" had me thrown for a bit (although the title should have given me a clue). He passed himself off to Harry as a future incarnation of the Doctor, but he's not. At first I thought he might be Big Finish's "Doctor" from an alternate reality (with whom I am wholly unfamiliar), but he's not that, either. Turns out he's [SPOILER] The Two, an earlier incarnation of The Eleven.*

    *For those of you who may not know, The Eleven is a Time Lord who, every time he regenerates, retains the personality of his previous incarnation, a sort of MPD Time Lord. He originally appeared on audio as an antagonist for the Eighth Doctor, but has since appeared as The Nine, The Twelve, and now The Two.

    I am now back on my once-a-week-on-Wednesday posting schedule.

    TRAILER

  • I was listening along with Jeff on the first few but listened to TWO'S COMPANY on my own. Jeff tried to give me a heads up on the Renegade Time Lord but I told him I wouldn't have trouble following along. I know Harry and this Time Lord from a later incarnation from UNIT. Kate Stewart and Osgood are some of my absolute favorite characters. The Renegade or The Eleven or whatever he was at the moment (in those other stories) tried to get the better of the UNIT crew but failed. Listening to TWO'S COMPANY was fun because he's not quite as obnoxious and has to tangle with Jackie Tyler. The necklace alien tech has a jeweled dial and Jackie fidgets with it when she's nervous. The sound effects are perfect. I can picture it clearly in my mind. The actress mentions on the script she is listed as "Lovable Loudmouth" and that had me laughing. That's a brilliant description of Jackie. 

  • I was listening along with Jeff on the first few but listened to TWO'S COMPANY on my own.

    ...and now she has moved ahead because I have chosen to listen only on Wednesdays.

    Jeff tried to give me a heads up on the Renegade Time Lord but I told him I wouldn't have trouble following along.

    The Eleven (and his various regenerations) was introduced and appears primarily in Eighth Doctor stories, which Tracy hasn't listened to. But what I didn't know, is that he/they have also appeared in UNIT stories which I have not listened to. 

    I know Harry and this Time Lord from a later incarnation from UNIT.

    She ended up clueing me in to what's up with Harry Sullivan these days.

    Listening to TWO'S COMPANY was fun because he's not quite as obnoxious

    ...or as insane.

  • Today's Wednesday so it must be time for...

    THE MARTIAN INVASION OF PLANETOID 50:

    large.jpg

    The First Doctor arrives in Victorian London amid a Martian invasion. But he discovers all is not what it seems when Missy appears...

    Soon, the Doctor is propelled into a future incarnation - the Tenth - but he is not alone in battling Missy and her Martian invaders. The Paternoster Gang - Madame Vastra, Jenny Flint and Strax - are also here to assist. But can they offer the Doctor any help in solving his own degeneration mystery?

    • The Doctor - David Tennant
    • Missy - Michelle Gomez
    • Madame Vastra - Neve McIntosh
    • Jenny Flint - Catrin Stewart
    • Strax - Dan Starkey
    • Jessamy Moore - Hannah Genesius

    With special appearances by:

    • The First Doctor - Stephen Noonan
    • TheThird Doctor - Tim Treloar

    This episode begins with the First doctor landing on what he thinks is Earth but is actually a planetoid made to mimic H.G. Wells' The War of the Worlds. It occurs to me I'm not certain who the "current" incarnation of the Doctor is supposed to be at this point, but the Tenth is a future incarnation (even the Doctor doesn't recognise himself). His personality is intact, but his "memories" are spotty (because he hasn't experienced them yet). This one is very funny. If hadn't been listening in the car and had been able to take notes, I would have jotted down some of the one-liners. Even without the context of the overall story, this one is worth listening to just to hear David Tennant and Michelle Gomez trying to "one-up" each other... and generally succeeding! Missy reveals that she also has undergone "degeneration" at one point in hhis/her lives

    TRAILER

    • "My dear Doctor, you have been naive", a callback to the Ainley Master, I beleive.

  • TIME LORD IMMEMORIAL:

    large.jpg

    Slipping between bodies, the Ninth Doctor finds his TARDIS caught between universes as the cosmos starts to break down. A Doctor from another reality arrives and they join forces with Liv Chenka and the Lumiat to find the cause. Someone has desecrated the mythical Hall of the Time Lord Immemorial, where the sands of time from the multiverse are held. And those sands are running out...

    • The Doctor - Christopher Eccleston
    • Alternate Universe Doctor - David Warner
    • Liv Chenka - Nicola Walker
    • The Lumiot - Gina McKee
    • The Time Lord Immemorial - Robert Powell

    This episode begins with the (Ninth) Doctor riffing on the word "union," a clue from the previous episode, but he doesn't know what it is, exactly. Suddenly, another Doctor appears in his TARDIS (or perhaps he appears in another Doctor's TARDIS; it isn't clear at first because the "desktop" keeps changing). They soon determine that they are from alternate universes, rather than one being a later incarnation of the other. I know nothing about the Alternate Universe Doctor other than that he is unique to Big Finish and has a series of his own. (With so many adventures of so many Doctors to choose from, I decided it was best to stick with the "official" ones.) they are soon attacked by sand creatures.

    "Meanwhile," Liv Chenka is on holiday, relaxing on a beach. If you don't know, Liv Chenka first appeared in the Big Finish Seventh Doctor adventure "The Robots of Life," a sequel to the Fourth Doctor TV adventure "The Robots of Death," but she is best known for her long tenure as companion to the Eighth Doctor. She is soon joined by the Lumiot, a future incarnation of the Master/Missy. The Lumiot is now a good friend and ally of the Doctor, and changed her name when her role changed. I know from the "extras" section that this is not the first appearance of the Lumiot, but it is Liv and the Ninth Doctor's first encounter with her, so it was pretty easy to follow. Soon the sands of the beach arise to attack Liv and the Lumiot.

    If you guessed that the sand men that attacked the Doctors and the sand that attacked Liv and the Lumiot are related, go to the head of the TARDIS. Soon the plots converge and they set about fulfilling a prophecy which will lead them to the mythical Time Lord Immemorial. The "prophecy" thing is kind of a cliché, but the poem is very good (and quite lengthy), and can be interpreted in multiple ways, which was fun. (Again, if I hadn't been listening in my car I would have jotted it down.) 

    There are lots of clues and lots of foreshadowing. Despite being a future incarnation, the Doctor seems to know Liz (although she does not know him). When they part he says, "Give my regards to Helen and Tonya," and she replies, "Helen and who?" I don't know if Big Finish listeners are supposed to know who "Tonya" is or not. I suspect not, although she may have been introduced at some point during my Big Finish hiatus. The Doctor, the AU Doctor and the Lumiot are all suffering from degeneration, but it had been held at bay during the course of this episode because of the situation. The AU Doctor is back in his home reality. Just before the Lumiot degenerates, she hints that Liz would not like any of her other selves just before she changes into one... but we don't know which. Just before the Doctor himself changes, he recieves a message from (wait for it)... Susan.

    TRAILER

  • THE UNION:

    large.jpg

    The Doctor responds to a distress call from his granddaughter, Susan, taking him to the Diamond Array: a huge multidimensional space station. Once there, his instability increases, as the Fourth and Eighth Doctors discover the Array's terrible purpose.

    Meanwhile, River Song has made a deadly alliance to try to save her husband. And the truth about the Doctor's degeneration will finally be revealed.

    • The Doctor - Paul McGann
    • The Doctor - Tom Baker
    • River Song - Alex Kingston
    • Susan - Carole Ann Ford

    With special appearances by:

    • The First Doctor - Stephen Noonan
    • The Second Doctor - Michael Troughton
    • TheThird Doctor - Tim Treloar
    • The Fifth Doctor - Peter Davison
    • The Sixth Doctor - Colin Baker
    • The Seventh Doctor - Sylvester McCoy
    • The Tenth Doctor - David Tennant
    • The Eleventh Doctor - Jacob Dudman
    • The Twelvth Doctor - Jacob Dudman
    • The Monk - Rufus Hound
    • The War Doctor - Jonathon Carley

    Big Finish really pulled out all the stops for this one. I have no idea how they recorded this one, but I imagine most of the parts were recorded separately at different times. The CD extras may go into that, but I haven't listed to that section yet. As a matter of fact, I still have a bit of the story left to listen to. Usually, I'll finish the story about halfway home from my LCS and still have time for the extras. Part 5 took me all the way home (no extras), but with this one I didn't even get finished (and that's with me driving 10 m.p.h. slower than usual due to heavy rain). 

    As the story begins, the Doctor's degeneration has become highly unstable. By the time he finds Susan, he has stabilized somewhat, fluctuating back and forth between his Eighth and Fourth selves. Other than the First Doctor, susan has become most closely associated with the Eighth (on audio), but I don't think she's ever met the Fourth before. Tom Baker and Carole Ann Ford have an excellent rapport with each other. the Eighth Doctor knows River Song but the Fourth does not, although I'm certain they've met before on audio. Either this story takes place before that one (from the Doctor's POV; she certainly knows him) or his memories are messed up from the degeneration. Also, Susan knows River; she was one of Susan's teachers at the Coal Hill School alongside Ian and Barbara. (I don't know if that's from an audio I haven't heard or foreshadowing of a story yet to come.) It was River who faked the message from Susan. River is working for the Union... at least she is pretending to. 

    The Union is actually [SPOILER] the Time Lord formerly known as the Eleven, but a future incarnation (as the Valeyard is the the Doctor). She comes from a time when all of her personalities have integrated... hence "the Union." She is, of course, the one responsible for the Doctor's (and other Time Lords') degeneration. It is the energy generated by this process which allows her to supress all of her other selves. [END SPOILER]. It has been vague up until this time, but the "present" of this story is set during the Time War. The difference between the Union and the Doctor is that her other selves drive her mad, whereas the Doctor draws strength from his... all except one. It was her shooting the War Doctor with her degeneration weapon which kicked off this series of events.

    Withing the Union's diamond Array, the Doctor begins to lose control of his degeneration again, switching rapidly between selves. Some of them begin "premembering" events that haven't happened, to them, yet. They even deliver a lengthy speech of defiance (with multiple callbacks), shifting among multiple Doctors a line at a time. It is at this point the Union reveals her ace in the hole, the War Doctor, but her scheme doesn't play out exactly the way she intended (see 4:18 clip below).

    TRAILER

    2:34 CLIP

    4:18 CLIP

     

This reply was deleted.