I always pronounced it with a hard "g", like "begin gold" without the "be"..

Views: 625

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hard (as in "ginkgo").

I always pronounce it gin as in "gin" and gold as in "gold", so put me down for one soft G and one hard G.

Clearly, that is how this entirely fictional word is pronounced.

Has DC ever given an official pronunciation?

Dave Elyea said:

I always pronounce it gin as in "gin" and gold as in "gold", so put me down for one soft G and one hard G.

I've always assumed hard G (well, two of them).  But on reflection, I recall that Ralph (Elongated Man) Dibny used the exclamation "By gingold!".  I wouldn't be at all surprised to find that the initial G was intended to be soft, so that Ralph's cry would sound like "By Jingo!"

Hard "g" for both.

Of course, I always pronounced it Thay-Nos as well, so what do I know? 

Interesting, not only in the differing ways we pronounce certain words from comics, but in the fact that I think there's a tendency to presume everyone else says it the same way one himself does.  For example, it never occurred to me that some folks might pronounce these differently than I do:

gingold (jin-gold)

Sub-Mariner (sub-MARE-in-er)

Jameson (as in "J. Jonah") (JAME-son)

Magneto (mag-NET-o)

"Mon-El", which I originally construed as "MUN-el", was the only one for which I ever saw a precise pronunciation.  In the letter column of Action Comics #  382 (Nov., 1969), Richard Jochner of San Leandro, California, wrote:

What is the correct pronunciation of Mon-El?  My friend and I have different ways of pronouncing it and would like to know the correct one.

To which, Mort Wesinger (or, more likely, E.Nelson Bridwell) responded:

It's pronounced "Moan-Ell"---you know, "moan"---like the Editor does when he sees a batch of letters pointing out boo-boos. 

From the moment I read that, back in '69, I immediately changed the way I pronounced "Mon-El" to the way that editorial response indicated.  After all, it came from the best authority.  But what has always surprised me is how some folks, who pronounced the name differently, after I informed them of how the Superman editor established the proper pronunciation, insisted that their pronunciations were still correct.

It goes back to how people can be illogically stubborn about things connected with grammar, even tangentially.  Continuing to pronounce "Mon-El" differently from how DC said it was pronounced is the same thing as telling the sixth president, John Quincy (who pronounced the "c" like a "z", as "Quinzy") Adams that he was wrong and his middle name was pronounced "Quin-see".

But, barring any sort of official establishment of the proper pronunciations for "gingold" or my other examples above, I'll gladly allow it's a matter of individual taste.  And if, somewhere, an official pronunciation has been established, and it's different from mine, I'll gladly change mine.

In the case of Namor, we have long-standing editorial insistence that Sub-Mariner be pronounced like "Ancient Mariner" (MAR-iner), and I have an issue somewhere that even mocks the "mar-EEner" pronunciation, despite generations of readers probably pronouncing it that way. That's how I initially said it, too.

They're now in position to put Subby into the MCU, so we'll finally get the definitive.... No, a lot of people will stay say, SubmaREEner, and it's not like a fictional character can complain.

I knew a kid in the 70s who pronounced "Gene Simmons" with a hard G. "Geen Simmons." I don't know if Witz/Klein/Simmons got that a lot, but I imagine he would complain, and he's only a semi-fictional character, so he can.

Funny, I always assumed that "Mon-El" was pronounced "Mawn-Ell".

Growing up in Boston, I learned early on that "Quincy" was pronounced "Kwinzee"..

In Legion of Three Worlds*, Winath was pronounced three different ways: WIN-ath, WINE-ath and Win-AYTH.

Legion of Three Pronunciations

I remember reading somewhere that if you hear someone pronounce a word incorrectly, it's probably because they learned it from reading and not from hearing it aloud. 

That's definitely true in my case. I still always trip over "pharmaceutical."

In my youth I didn't talk comics with others, so it was just from reading.

gingold (I always used the hard G)

Sub-Mariner (submarine-er until I heard it said correctly on the 1960s "motion comics")*

* the narrator on an Iron Man episode thought the word "origin" was pronounced like the beginning of the word "original."

Jameson (I always pronounced in JAM-MES-SON)

Magneto (mag-NET-o until I heard it correctly when I started attending comic conventions)

Mon-El: (I was there when he was introduced in 1961. Like Solomon Grundy, he showed up on Monday. He was supposedly a member of the El family, so he was called Mon-El (why did he need a new name---Amnesia?). So it should be MUN-El, but I still silently called him MON-El.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Groups

Latest Activity

Richard Willis replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
2 hours ago
The Baron posted a discussion

The World War Two Su[er-Hero I Would Tell If I Could Use Any Characters I wanted

If I could "recruit" whatever characters from whichever comics company I wished and tell any kind…See More
6 hours ago
ClarkKent_DC replied to Cavaliere (moderator emeritus)'s discussion What are you watching right now?
"I've got George Carlin's Class Clown on vinyl. I used to play it incessantly. He actually…"
10 hours ago
ClarkKent_DC replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
"Yeah, but ... here on Earth-Prime, when they gave us the Smallville TV series, Ma and Pa Kent were…"
10 hours ago
ClarkKent_DC replied to ClarkKent_DC's discussion A Capitol Fourth -- Happy Independence Day!
"We ventured out yesterday for this year's rendition of A Capitol Fourth. This was the first…"
11 hours ago
Jeff of Earth-J replied to Jeff of Earth-J's discussion Swamp Thing
"Thanks for the link! I forgot to mention that #78 was guest-written by Bissette (and…"
11 hours ago
Richard Willis posted a video

Paper Girls - Teaser Trailer | Prime Video

It's the day after Halloween in 1988 when four young friends accidentally stumble into an intense time war and find themselves inexplicably transported to th...
11 hours ago
Richard Willis replied to Jeff of Earth-J's discussion Swamp Thing
"A new interview with Stephen Bissette about his career and new work: INTERVIEW: Stephen Bissette…"
12 hours ago
Steve W replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
"Enuf Supes - here's Archie."
12 hours ago
Richard Willis replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
"Steve W said: By 1967, DC had reached a continuity crisis. Supes had first hit the newsstands in…"
12 hours ago
Richard Willis replied to Cavaliere (moderator emeritus)'s discussion What are you watching right now?
"Another interesting thing is that the series is a period piece set in the 1970s. In the enormous…"
12 hours ago
Steve W replied to Steve W's discussion A Cover a Day
"By 1967, DC had reached a continuity crisis. Supes had first hit the newsstands in 1938, so when DC…"
12 hours ago

© 2022   Captain Comics, board content ©2013 Andrew Smith   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service