Amazingly enough, most aren't from the last ten years."
I do disagree with a few though.
You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
Amazingly enough, most aren't from the last ten years."
I do disagree with a few though.
You need to be a member of Captain Comics to add comments!
Replies
I agree with most of them. There are a handful that I don't know.
"Wasp Johnson is right!"
The one I'm surprised isn't there is the Paul Smith panels from X-Men 173 or 174 where Wolverine stabs himself to get the opponent behind him. (Or is that from Wolverine Limited Series? .... Can't remember)
Edit: Nope, not the X-Men issue I was thinking ... that's a fight versus Silver Samurai. Still, I love this sequence from 173.
There are quite a few of them I disagree with. Many of them conflate iconic moments with iconic panels. It's an interesting springboard for discussion.
Looking through the panels, I sort of felt as if the person who put them together hadn't read enough comics to be compiling such a list.
A few of my thoughts:
1. No. I'd have chosen the very last panel of the story
2. No (not even the Kirby original if I'm correct)
3. Maybe...
4. Yes
5. No. There's a better panel later in the story.
6. Maybe
7. Yes
8. Yes
9. Maybe...it's really hard to pick one panel from that origin story.
10. At the time it came out, yes. Now, no.
11. Yes
12. Yes
13. Maybe
14. Yes
15. No
16. Nope.
17. Yes
18. Yes (if only it had stayed that way)
19. No.
20. Maybe
21. No.
22. Yes, begrudgingly.
23. I like it, but no
24. No
25. No
26. Yes.
27. Yes
28. No.
29. Yes.
30. Yes
31. No
32. No
33. No
34. No
35. No
36. Maybe
37. No
38. No
39. I love it, but no.
40. No.(No advantageous claws?)
41. No.
42. Yes
43. No.
44. Yes.
45. No.
46. No. I thought there were better moments of Skurge's last stand.
47. Yes
48. No
49. No
50. No
51. Funny, but no.
52. I hate to admit it, but yes.
53. No.
54. Yes.
55. No.
56. No.
57. No.
58. No.
59. No
60. No.
61. No.
62. No.
63. No.
64. No.
65. No.
66. No.
67. Maybe.
68. Yes.
69. No.
70. No.
Should a list of "iconic panels" include splash pages? (Nos. 10, 11, 24, 29, 31, 38, 40, 43, 44, 54, 55, 56, 58, 59, 63, 64, 66) I wouldn't think so.
I certainly think such a list should not include splash pages that have been cropped (Nos. 22, 47).
Randy Jackson said:
What he said.
Also ...
No Iron Man?
No Incredible Hulk?
No Sgt. Fury and His Howling Commandos?
No Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.?
No Marvel Team-Up?
No Marvel Two-in-One/The Thing?
No Black Panther?
No Luke Cage, Hero for Hire?
No Power Man/Iron Fist?
No Ghost Rider?
No Tomb of Dracula?
Randy,
Your list of responses brings to mind an old movie ad campaign. An announcer's voice said, "And now, Woody Allen with a few answers to questions about his new movie "Sleeper"...
Cut to Woody sitting alone at a conference table who simply says,
"Yes"
"Yes"
"No, definitely not."
"Only with a banana once"
"Absolutely NOT"
"Well, yes".
And that's all they shared. You never got the questions.
They cut directly to a screen as the announcer says "Now playing everywhere".
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next